Author: Pete Galati
Date: 14:51:25 02/09/01
Go up one level in this thread
On February 09, 2001 at 17:37:26, Uri Blass wrote: >On February 09, 2001 at 16:54:13, Pete Galati wrote: > >>On February 09, 2001 at 15:45:05, leonid wrote: >> >>>On February 09, 2001 at 11:51:37, Pete Galati wrote: >>> >>>>On February 09, 2001 at 08:40:05, Uri Blass wrote: >>>> >>>>>On February 09, 2001 at 08:25:02, Hans Havermann wrote: >>>>> >>>>>>On February 09, 2001 at 06:51:15, leonid wrote: >>>>>> >>>>>>>>[D]1bqQBnRn/3N2Qb/Q1QN2np/1Q1Q1qpk/4Qqbn/2B1Qrnn/2Q5/K1R5 w - - >>>>>> >>>>>>Black has too many promotions. :) >>>>> >>>>>Right. >>>>> >>>>>Most chess programs cannot analyze positions when black has 7 promotions and 2 >>>>>pawns. >>>>> >>>>>Chessbase programs do not accept the position and the engine is not >>>>>important(after Board, Setup position,paste Fen I cannot tell the program ok. >>>>> >>>>>I think that it is a bug in the chessbase interface because the interface is >>>>>made for many engines and it is possible that some of the engines have no >>>>>problem to analyze the illegal position. >>>>> >>>>>I think that the interface should allow putting illegal position in the board >>>>>and I do not understand the decision not to allow putting illegal positions. >>>>> >>>>>Uri >>>> >>>>Well, look at it this way though, this position crashes Crafty when I paste it >>>>into Crafty running in text mode, and I can paste the position into Winboard, >>>>but niether TCB nor Crafty will analyze the position once it's there. I suppose >>>>I could fix the position so it IS legal, but then it would be a different >>>>position. >>>> >>>>Pete >>> >>>I have no idea why in Crafty it could be the problem to solve position like >>>above. I never used Crafty for this purpose. I used it only for playing chess. >>>Great program! But I was very interested to know why many of programs that I >>>used around 4 eyars ago crashed on positions, even every modest compared with >>>the last one. Now I only have some guessing about what it could be. Maybe some >>>programs use some look-up tables that is the beginning for all limitations. >>>Maybe number of moves was limited for each ply, taking in consideration that DOS >>>was very restrictive system. I just don't know... >>> >>>Leonid. >> >>Well, fwiw, I removed one Queen, the one on Wht's 8th rank, and then Crafty >>didn't mind the position >> >>[D]1bq1BnRn/3N2Qb/Q1QN2np/1Q1Q1qpk/4Qqbn/2B1Qrnn/2Q5/K1R5 w - - 0 1 >> >>but I have no idea how important that Queen was to that position. With the >>position like that, Crafty is intent on doing Nxf5 but it hasn't shown me # yet. >> >>Pete > >The queen is very important to the solution. >The first move of the solution of chest is Qd8xg5+ Ok, I wasn't paying attention to what programs had com up with for a solution. > >Chessbase interface is not going to accept not removing black pieces. >The reason that chessbase does not accept it is the fact that there are too many >black pieces. Crafty wouldn't have noticed that I suppose because the position is Wht to move. > >If you want to get a position that chessbase accept then a good idea is to >replace the pawn at g5 by a rook. > >Uri But we'd still have to get rid of one Wht Queen though I think. Are any of them not needed? Crafty did finally see a mate with that Queen missing, but it doesn't keep Blk in check the whole time. Pete 8 65:52 Mat09 1. Nxf5 Nhxf5 2. Bxg6+ Kh4 3. Qxh6+ Nh5 4. Be1+ Rg3 5. Qxh5+ Bxh5 6. Qxg3+ Nxg3 7. Qxg5+ Nxg5 8. Qh2+ Kg4 9. Qxg3# 8-> 90:44 Mat09 1. Nxf5 Nhxf5 2. Bxg6+ Kh4 3. Qxh6+ Nh5 4. Be1+ Rg3 5. Qxh5+ Bxh5 6. Qxg3+ Nxg3 7. Qxg5+ Nxg5 8. Qh2+ Kg4 9. Qxg3#
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.