Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: When not to delete a post

Author: Don Prohaska

Date: 14:53:19 07/08/98

Go up one level in this thread


On July 08, 1998 at 15:36:40, Steven Schwartz wrote:

>On July 08, 1998 at 15:22:18, Bruce Moreland wrote:
>
>>I can't help but keep thinking about something that happened a while back, and I
>>apologize for starting another non-chess thread, but this is bothering me.
>>
>>Vincent wrote a post that had something to do with killer books.
>>
>>A moderator responded, I'm not sure it was the first response, but it was early
>>on, something to the effect of, "this is factualy wrong, you have been told this
>>before, but you won't believe this, let's delete this post."  Another moderator
>>came along and said, "Yes, delete it".
>>
>>Before Steven could delete it, I think there was another post that said, "no,
>>don't delete this!".  Maybe that was mine, I don't remember, but I think there
>>was at least one non-me involved.
>>
>>Did I dream this, or did it actually happen, and was that post actually deleted?
>>
>>I would like to know what people think about the idea of deleting posts like
>>this.
>>
>>Personally I think this is a bad reason to delete a post.
>>
>>bruce
>
>
>I believe that there are VERY few good reasons to delete a post.
>
>Certainly someone being wrong is not a good reason to delete a post;
>otherwise, half of the posts on this board would be gone. I cannot
>recall a single post that was deleted because someone was simply
>wrong.
>
>- Steve
Not too long ago a certain person claimed that the addresses from ccc were given
to a commercial entity and that entity then spammed the members of ccc. That
person was wrong and was told he was wrong and he knew he was wrong. Later he
gave this "wrong" information several times at rgcc. Now, are you telling me
that a post like that can linger on? Why should falsehoods be allowed to live
on? When it is read it can be believed as true. After all, not everyone has the
time to check out all the messages on ccc. If you must leave falsehoods on ccc,
I suggest that a note be apended stating that the comments have proven false!
This BS that everything be permitted is crazy. PERIOD!



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.