Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: perft weirdness - getting weirder

Author: Andreas Guettinger

Date: 13:05:31 01/02/03

Go up one level in this thread


On January 02, 2003 at 15:51:30, Russell Reagan wrote:

>[D]r3k2r/8/8/8/8/8/8/1R2K2R b Kkq - 0 1
>
>In the above position, I calculate perft 3:
>
>> perft 3
>26      0
>583     0
>14251   0.032
>total time: 0.032
>
>Other engines say that perft 3 is 14252, so I assume that I am wrong here and I
>went looking for the position where the error is. I wrote a function to tell me
>preft (n-1) for each of the legal moves so I can tell which branch the error is
>in, and I continue to narrow it down until I find the offending position. This
>has worked well so far, but now I'm getting this:
>
>> dperft 3
>h8h1    87      87
>a8a1    356     443
>a8a2    544     987
>a8a3    631     1618
>a8a4    631     2249
>a8a5    631     2880
>a8a6    631     3511
>a8a7    631     4142
>a8b8    524     4666
>a8c8    559     5225
>a8d8    488     5713
>h8h2    428     6141
>h8h3    547     6688
>h8h4    575     7263
>h8h5    602     7865
>h8h6    628     8493
>h8h7    650     9143
>h8f8    490     9633
>h8g8    560     10193
>e8d7    720     10913
>e8e7    742     11655
>e8f7    692     12347
>e8d8    510     12857
>e8f8    490     13347
>e8g8    474     13821
>e8c8    431     14252
>
>This function reports perft n-1 for each move, and keeps a running total on the
>right. The last number in the right column is, to my suprise, 14252, which is
>the correct perft 3.
>
>So when I calculate perft 3, it is incorrect, but when I ask it to give me a
>breakdown of perft 2 for each move, the sum (which should be the same as what I
>am getting for perft 3) is suddenly correct.
>
>Any idea what this could mean? I'm stumped...


Strange.
Do you have a nodes--; somewhere when you iterate back out of your search
function?
But this would have nothing to do with castling...

regards
Andy



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.