Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Testresults WAC, LCT II, WM (K)

Author: Drexel,Michael

Date: 14:59:35 09/28/03


Q: Why?
A: to get an idea which programs are best suitable for interactive Analysis.

Demand: solution time <1 min even for "tough" positions.

Q: Why?
A: Obviously you dont want to spend more than a minute on a single position if
you want to analyse your games in reasonable time.

AMD,1.8 GHz,512MB (ordinary Hardware)

64MB hash,CB-GUI

LCT II(few tough positions), 60 secs, 1 extra ply:

   program             pos. solved     time(solved av./all av.)

1. Hiarcs 9              30/35          2.52s/10.73s  !!

2. Shredder 7.04         30/35          5.16s/13.00s  !

3. Fritz 7.008           28/35          4.77s/15.81s

4. Ruffian 1.01          28/35          5.78s/16.62s

5. TheKing 3.23 AntiCM   28/35          6.85s/17.48s

6. TheKing 3.23 Pillen   27/35          6.81s/18.96s

7. The King 3.23 default 26/35          5.68s/16.64s

8. Delfi 4.3             25/35          5.59s/21.14s


WM-Test King attack (many tough positions), 60 secs, 1 extra ply:

1. TheKing 3.23 AntiCM   21/38          15.42s/35.36s  !!

2. TheKing 3.23 Pillen   19/38          13.78s/36.89s  !

3. Shredder 7.04         17/38          15.35s/40.02s

4. TheKing 3.23 default  15/38          23.11s/45.75s

5. Fritz 7.0.0.8         15/38          25.71s/46.46s

6. Hiarcs 9              13/38          17.53s/45.47s

7. Ruffian 1.01          10/38          21.64s/49.90s

8. Delfi 4.3              4/38          15.81s/55.34s


WAC(very easy positions), 1 sec, 1 extra ply

1. TheKing 3.23 Pillen    288/300         0.09s/0.13s  !!

2. TheKing 3.23 default   287/300         0.08s/0.12s  !

3. TheKing 3.23 AntiCM    285/300         0.07s/0.12s

4. Hiarcs 9               285/300         0.20s/0.24s

5. Ruffian 1.01           284/300         0.29s/0.32s

6. Delfi 4.3              282/300         0.49s/0.52s

7. Shredder 7.04          279/300         0.38s/0.42s

8. Fritz 7.008            279/300         0.44s/0.48s

(for comparison: Comet B60 269/300, GLC 3.0 277/300, Crafty 19.03 277/300,
 Yace Paderborn 280/300, Little Goliath 3.9 281/300, Knight Dreamer 3 282/300)

I cant test Junior,Chesstiger,Rebel or Deep Sjeng in CB-GUI at present.
In WM-Test King attack they should perform clearly worse than
Chessmaster,Shredder or Fritz.

Michael




This page took 0.03 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.