Author: Harald Faber
Date: 07:38:03 10/20/03
Go up one level in this thread
On October 20, 2003 at 08:41:19, David H. McClain wrote: >> >> >>First: Read again some lines above where I marked the important lines a bit. If >>you still don't understand it I can mark the keywords. >> >>Second: It is easy to criticize but hard to do it better. Why don't you jump on >>that train and do it yourself? Get yourself 2x AMD1200 and play CM 9000 original >>(!!) with 40/120+20/60 vs. Fritz 8, Hiarcs 9, Junior 8, Shredder 7.04, each >>match over 40 games. >>Feel free to send the games to SSDF then so that they can include those >>authentic games to their rating list and database. > >Harold, > >You cannot see the forrest for the trees. Why doesn't SSDF contact the >independent testers for their games using Chessmaster? There are enough games >listed for download on the Internet by reliable and credible people to be >included for a reliable test. I have the games downloaded, why don't you >download them and send them to SSDF? This subject reappears all the time simply >because it is so obvious. > >It's like evaluating the best automobiles in the world for all to see and not >including Mercedes Benz or Porsche. > >DHM Is it so difficult to understand? The games YOU downloaded, are they played under the SSDF conditions? Here they are: - 2 PCs - permanent brain ON - engine opening book -> no draw book, no "Kurzbuch" etc. - time control 40 moves in 120 minutes then 20 moves in 60 minutes and so on No, they are NOT. What you have is a collection of Utzingers games, maybe with CM 9000_Utz12n and/or CM 9000_SKR. Then some games from Markus Pillen with CM 9000_Pillen. Maybe some more by Chessfun with CM 9000_Chessfun or CM 9000_Morphy etc etc. And you think you can throw them into SSDF? Those games are played - with different opening books - on ONE PC - wihtout permanent brain - time control maximum 40 moves in 40 minutes IIRC So if you still say "throw the games into the SSDF list" there are only 4 words left to say.
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.