Author: Bruce Moreland
Date: 14:02:39 11/09/98
Go up one level in this thread
On November 09, 1998 at 12:41:37, Reynolds Takata wrote: >Shaun Graham, wanted protection from harassment by an individual to remain >unnamed. What i saw was that the unnamed individual agreed to leave Shaun alone >in other words stay out of his articles, and Shaun would agreed to do the same. >The unnamed Individual broke the agreement several times and Shaun went on a >campaign to get the administrators to protect him from the assault. I agreed >with Shaun because it brings a bad light on the group when members lie in the >group. The difference however between Shaun and Moritz was that Shaun was >zealous in his fight to get the administrators to protect him(Many, Many >Posts!). It seemed he was ticked off because the admins sort of gave the >attotude, "We don't care if he's right" this is what we are going to do blah bla >blah and there's nothing you can do about it. Moritz started to fight, but i >guess he realized more reasonably perhaps that, the current administration was >not going to help, so he just decided to leave. I thought I wrote a good post about this in September. It is not the moderators' job to arbitrate minor disputes between members, if the CCC charter is not used to arbitrate them. It should not be possible for two or more members to make recognized agreements that amend or abrogate the CCC charter as relates to these members. And by that I mean that it should not be possible for two members agree that any contact between them should be considered abuse, nor should it be possible for two members to agree that they can abuse each other without being subject to moderation. It is just too confusing to try to do anything else. If someone wants to create a complex agreement like this, where any sort of contact is considered abuse, then they can always enforce it outside of CCC, without involving the moderators. What I saw in that particular case was an abusive post asking for moderation because someone else posted something that wasn't abusive, and I responded on that basis. bruce
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.