Author: Tord Romstad
Date: 04:49:21 12/16/03
Go up one level in this thread
On December 16, 2003 at 02:26:09, Uri Blass wrote: >I am almost sure that you can find more than 20 free winboard programs with >better results than Crafty in ecm-gcp and it is not surprising for me. > >I will even not be surprised if you find 30 free programs that are better than >Crafty in ecm-gcp. Yes, it seems so. I managed to find the following list in an old post by Thomas Mayer on the Winboard forum. The first column is the number of solutions found in 10 seconds, while the second column is the total solve time (I'm not sure precisely what it means). The tests were run on an Athlon 1.8 GHz. If we agree to be generous towards Crafty, we can compare these results to Crafty's results at 30 seconds/position. Crafty solved 113 positions, which would put it on place 32 in the list. If we include Gothmog on the list (133/183 in 10 seconds on a PIV 2.4 GHz, which for my engine is almost exactly equivalent to an Athlon 1.8 GHz), Crafty drops to place 33. If we subtract the commercials (The King, Rebel, WBNimzo, Gandalf and Deep Sjeng), we are left with at least 27 free engines which score better than Crafty in ecm-gcp. Of course, most of these engines are nowhere near as strong as Crafty. TheKing 3.23 Sel.12 150 503 KnightDreamer v3.1b 146 533 Rebel 12 - Rebel 141 646 Tao v5.4 140 657 Little Goliath v3.9 139 639 Bringer v1.9 137 694 WBNimzo 2000b 137 712 Phalanx 22 132 714 Ruffian 1.0.1 132 789 Gandalf 4.32h 131 693 Yace Paderborn 130 709 Delfi 4.1 126 814 WBNimzo 2000a 126 816 Ktulu v3.6 126 874 Deep Sjeng 1.5 125 776 Resp v0.19 124 824 The Crazy Bishop 123 869 Green Light Chess v3.00 122 839 SmarThink 0.16b 121 810 Sunsetter C7 121 828 AnMon 5.22 119 841 Amy 0.8.3 119 929 Movei 008 117 853 Pepito v1.59 116 850 Arasan version 6.3 116 970 Pharaon 2.62 116 983 Sjeng 12.13 115 906 King of Kings 2.10 115 912 Capture 115 958 Aristarch 4.4 115 962 Gromit 3.82 114 950 Quark v2.14beta 112 911 Nejmet 3.06 109 985 Dragon 4.43 107 760 Thinker 4.4e 105 1022 LambChop 10.99 104 1062 Horizon 4.02 103 1099 ExChess 4.03 99 1046 Chezzz 1.0.3 99 1105 WildCat 2.79 97 1058 Gromit 2.20 95 1138 Gaviota 0.33 94 1115 The Baron 0.99.5a 94 1139 Ant v6.06 93 1133 Abrok 4.0 92 1096 Leila053h 92 1116 Comet B.60 92 1130 SOS 991103 92 1183 Amyan 1.59 90 1147 KnightX 1.77 89 1184 Esc 1.16 88 1138 Freyr 10.67 87 1171 Beowulf 2.2 87 1216 LordKing 4 86 1151 Hagrid 07.56 86 1199 Queen 2.37 85 1199 Fortress 1.62 84 1255 Frenzee 142.4.1 81 1245 Requiem v0.53 79 1198 Monarch 2002-04c 79 1200 Amateur 2.4 78 1242 Bestia v0.90 78 1275 Averno v0.40 76 1303 GnuChess 4.14 75 1286 Genesis 2.0 74 1304 Scidlet 3.4 73 1318 EnginMax 5.11c 71 1299 Armageddon 2.13.1 71 1400 Chispa 3.0 67 1356 Gerbil, Release 02 64 1334 Ufim 3.02 64 1382 Duke 1.0 58 1360 Plywood 1.7.3 55 1437 GreKo 2.15 55 1455 Tristram 4.16 54 1290 Dorky v3.4 54 1413 Trace v1.00 52 1464 RDChess V3.19 52 1471 Holmes 0.8.20k 51 1446 Olithink v3.05 42 1503 Ghost v0.13 42 1533 Matheus-1.9 40 1521 Celes 0.75c 39 1534 Cilian v4.13 39 1588 Asterisk v0.36 33 1591 Mint v2.3 31 1617 Skaki v1.19 28 1633 ChesterfieldCL 28 1649 DrunkenMaster v0.4 27 1649 Monik v2.11 27 1661 Grizzly v1.40.1b 27 1674 PolarEngine 1.3 24 1674 Simontacchi v1.4 21 1689 Jester v0.83 21 1708 Bace v4.6 19 1704 Beaches 1.5 19 1710 Pooky 1.8 17 1723 Robin 0.96 beta 16 1701 Small potato 0.6.0 15 1714 SdBC V0.3.9.0 15 1747 CEFAP 0.60 11 1741 StAndersen 1.31 11 1763 WJChess 1.31 10 1760 Zotron 2003 ALPHA 9 1740 Tord
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.