Author: Harald Faber
Date: 02:31:42 01/18/04
Go up one level in this thread
On January 17, 2004 at 19:17:13, F. Huber wrote: >On January 17, 2004 at 18:10:44, Harald Faber wrote: > >>On January 17, 2004 at 12:45:30, Christophe Theron wrote: >> >>>On January 17, 2004 at 07:59:09, Harald Faber wrote: >>> >>>>On January 17, 2004 at 06:07:33, Ed Schröder wrote: >>>> >>>>>On January 16, 2004 at 19:06:21, Harald Faber wrote: >>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>>[D]2r1k1b1/pp4Q1/3p4/q5p1/4P3/1PN2P2/PP6/1K5R b - - 0 1 >>>>>> >>>>>>Analysis by Shredder 8: >>>>>> >>>>>>1. +- (#153): 33...Lf7 34.Th8+ Ke7 35.Txc8 d5 36.Sxd5+ Kd6 37.Dxf7 De1+ 38.Tc1 >>>>>>Dc3 39.bxc3 b5 40.Dxa7 Kc6 41.Dc7# >>>>>>2. +- (#151): 33...Tc7 34.Dxg8+ Kd7 35.Sd5 Tc2 36.Th7+ Kc6 37.Dc8+ Dc7 38.Txc7+ >>>>>>Kb5 39.Kxc2 a5 40.Dxb7# >>>>>>3. +- (#7): 33...De5 34.Dxg8+ Kd7 35.Th7+ De7 36.Txe7+ Kxe7 37.Dxc8 >>>>> >>>>>Harald, >>>>> >>>>>Can you proof your claim? >>>>> >>>>>Ed :) >>>> >>>>Sure. >>>>33...Lf7 34.Th8+ Ke7 35.Txc8 d5 36.Sxd5+ Kd6 37.Dxf7 De1+ 38.Tc1 Dc3 39.bxc3 b5 >>>>40.Dxa7 Kc6 41.Dc7# is #8, not #153 >>>> >>>>33...Tc7 34.Dxg8+ Kd7 35.Sd5 Tc2 36.Th7+ Kc6 37.Dc8+ Dc7 38.Txc7+ Kb5 39.Kxc2 a5 >>>>40.Dxb7# is #7, not #151. >>>> >>>>Do you count 151 or 153 moves in those mate lines? ;-))) >>> >>> >>>You did not give proof that there is no mate in 153! :) >>> >>> Christophe >> >> >>No, I gave only the proof that the given mating line is a mate in 8 and not a >>mate in 153 as Shredders eval suggests... ;) >> >>For the record: I don't consider this a serious bug. It is just a minor flaw the >>user should be aware of. > >Hello Harald, > >you are in ´good company´ with Shredder 8 ;-) - >both of you are wrong! > >After 33...Lf7 it´s NOT #8 (your wrong guess) >After 33...Tc7 it´s NOT #7 (------ " -------) >After 33...De5 it´s NOT #7 (Shredders guess) ---> is indeed #8 > >I´ve tested all three moves (33...) with ChestUCI, and all of those three >pvs are not correct - >so not only Shredder but also you must have a bug. ;-) > >Regards, >Franz. No bug. I have just counted Shredders moves in the mate lines. They provide the information I showed you. Seems as you don't get the point. No matter if you count 7 or 8 moves in Shredders displayed mate lines, it is FAR less and absolutely different from the given eval of #153 or #151.
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.