Author: Rolf Tueschen
Date: 14:05:37 01/31/04
Go up one level in this thread
Ich habe Fritz selbst geraten sich bei der fragwürdigen Art wie die Sache ihm vorgetragen wurde (ohne Angabe konkreter Gründe, ... andere Programmierer haben dies oder jenes gesagt ... !) nicht darauf einzugehen, die Engine nicht vorzulegen (wo kommen wir denn da hin?) und diesen Ausschluß zu riskieren, es gab für Fritz wichtigere Dinge als nach Graz zu reisen und auf unbestimmte Vorwürfe zu reagieren. Christian, I translate your newest statement about LIST and Fritz Reul, [quote CL] "I [Christian Liebert] have advised [!!!] Fritz to NOT accept to present the engine - because where do we get from here? - so to risk this exclusion, since Fritz had more important things to do as to travel [sic!] to Graz and to react on non-specified allegations -- on the background the affair was presented to him (without concrete reasons, -- other programmers should have said this or that --!)." [quote end] COMMENT: This goes too far, Christian, now you spoiled the whole thing unter pretetion that you are still speaking in favour of Fritz Reul. But the truth is that you do harm him with such declarations. Why? Because you imply that the procedures of the ICGA officials - without giving exact quotes and reasons of the allegations - were not-kosher. But exactly this is false, they were kosher as far as the rules are concerned. They were practically nonsense three rounds before the end of the tournament with the exclusion, but formally they were ok. Where in the history of justice the officials had to present their exact evidence to the defendent??? Give me a good example. Where? Nowhere! You wont find an example. After the rules such a questioning was allowed and therefore in order. They had no reason to inform Fritz Reul about all the evidence in advance. I think, Christian, next time you shoulkd reflect a bit deeper how you can make arguments in favour of a friend. Here you did harm Fritz Reul. And if YOU had advised him to play dickhead like you have described the reasoning, then you were damned wrong in doing so!! Rolf
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.