Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Fair uses for "Free engines".

Author: Eric Oldre

Date: 11:25:26 12/16/04


GOAL: to increase the volume of testing I can do in a given time period for my
engine, against a variety of opponents.

IDEA: To enlist the help of some friends! So when I have a new version of my
engine. I can send them my version along with several other engines and a series
of matches can be run. When finished they can send me the results back. I would
try to automate this process as much as possible.

Right now it seems that many of the engines that I would want to use to test
against simply describe themselves as "Free". Do you think that for those
engines the use I am planning for them would be acceptable?

THE PROBLEM:
I'm not sure if this strategy would break the "fair use" principles of the
engines I am testing against. My guess is that the licensing of some engines
(for sure commercial) would prohibit this use. Right now it seems that many of
the engines that I would want to use simply describe themselves as "Free". But
I’m not 100% sure that this particular use would be considered OK.

I'm looking for advice on:
a) What engines specifically would allow/deny this use?
b) How should I interpret the licensing of different engines to determine if I
am using them in a fair manner?

Right now my engine (Latista) is still pretty weak. But I hope that it will
improve over time. So I need to come up with a list of engines which would be
free for this use with a wide variety of strengths.

Thanks for your input!

Eric Oldre

If you are the author of an engine and are ok with me directly sending it to my
friends for use in testing my engine, feel free to let me know in a reply to
this thread, or email me. For those that do, THANK YOU IN ADVANCE!



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.