Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Dear Karinsdad and Dan. (It was Bionic Vs Crafty Debate)

Author: Fernando Villegas

Date: 05:46:51 01/27/99

Go up one level in this thread


Hi both:
Well, you ask me a document or fact of any kind about Bob willingness, about his
attitude respect Crafty. Simple: just take a look at the posts he has done about
this issue. Sorry, I am not going to do the search for you, as maybe I should:
no time for that. But If you can put faith in my memory and good will, what Bob
has said is that the very nature of his Crafty proyect is to live it open to use
and be changed or altered from any person interested and he only ask to receive
a feedback about how good or bad the changes were. And if my meorya does not
fail, what bothers Bob -and me- is the fact that clones of Crafty can be used
and compete. I agree with him in that in the degree the sons of Crafty are no
more than clones. Bionic is still a case to examine. We have now a downloadable
Bionic so we can see that for ourselves.
Of course I understand what All rights reserved means. Nevertheless, "reserved"
has not an absolute and unique meaning. What you reserve depoends of what you
want to reserve. Bill gates reserves something very different for Windows that
what Bob reserves for himself. Bob has said: do what you want but send me the
feedbakc, recognizee my autorship in the original product, etc. The authors os
Bionic has complied with art laest one of those petitions. maybe they are
failing in sending back to Bob the entire source code of Bionic.
Conclusion: In my view the sin of bionic people is something to be examined in
facts and not something to be stablished from now on, a priori,  on legal or
moral terms.  We must see the bowells of Bionic to see how much they really
putted new into it. Even some people believes the version that played in the
first half of the tournament was just a Crafty.
Greetings for all of you.
Fernando writting now from Spaceship Babylon



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.