Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Any games between Rybka and Hiarcs 10? [Moderation]

Author: Jonas Cohonas

Date: 19:07:52 12/13/05

Go up one level in this thread


>>Maybe you are new to internet forums (special interest ones), and it still seem
>>a bit unreal to you.
>>Anyway, of course, you may "question" programmers. But you should imagine you
>>are sitting right opposite them, too, and how they might feel. Some of them have
>>their livelihood at stake, too. That doesn't mean that you are working for them,
>>or that your post should affect things, and even if it does, it shouldn't be
>>your problem. But you would understand that they might get a bit nervous,
>>because the onus is on them to answer your post, and they should be a bit like a
>>protected species, when they go on show in the forum. AND, your post CAN make
>>some people decide "Well? oh no, ok, so I won't buy this one", because of an
>>unreasoned outburst about the particular program. And, it's not fair to expect a
>>programmer to protect himself each time this is done, when there is nothing
>>factual to which he can reply.
>>S.Taylor
>
>
>Okay S. Taylor
>
>
> Your post sounds very reasonable I admitt. But You have to remember Hiarcs is a
>very established Program with Professional Chessplayers having given it praise,
>Surely my little comment about it sucking isn't going to hurt the Programmers
>Feeling give me a break. If you were referring to somethingelse let me know.

Stuarts post was, by your own admission, reasonable and imo sums up some
important points about forums like this.

Now bare the S.Taylor reason in mind, why is it so important for you to defend
your right to use particular words which you should know by now is not accepted
here, atleast not from a social point of view. Whenever some wording or
particular way of expressing your view, like "this or that sucks" is not
accepted by the social standards of the forum, then it is the moderators job to
step in and point that out and believe me you are not the first to find that out
and sadly not the last...

Unlike say an open political forum where the charter grants you total freedom of
speech, this is about computer chess and is not a right, it is a privilege and
with that privilige comes certain responsibilities which can be read about in
the charter or in cases like this pointed out by the moderators, if you don't
like it, i suggest you find some place else which is more "open" to such
expressions that you feel are so important to you.

Regards
Jonas



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.