Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Kasparov's manager answers Hsu

Author: Frederic Friedel

Date: 17:20:48 01/13/00


We received the following reaction to the open letter published by F.H. Hsu. It
is by Garry Kasparov’s manager Owen Williams. Garry himself is on a flight to
Holland, on his way to the GM tournament in Wijk aan Zee. The letter is also on
Mark Crowther's site, or will be there soon.

Feng Hsiung Hsu's open letter is extraordinarily misleading and he demonstrates
a troubling ability to ignore certain responses and to take items out of context
or make them up and put them in his letter as facts. In his Open Letter he says:

"...Owen never said a straight yes or no to my question of whether Kasparov was
interested in a match. "

If you read the next paragraph, you will see his inability to read plain
English.  On Nov. 30th, I had responded as follows:

"With regard to a match against a computer, Garry would be  happy to consider a
Challenge under the right circumstances with the rules carefully laid out."

I went on to explain to Mr. Hsu that for Garry to consider a match, the
prizemoney would have to be substantial, that putting his World Title on the
line with an untried and untested opponent did not make any sense at all and
suggested politely but firmly that Mr. Hsu would have to get his program up and
running on his own or with a backer and then play many games including other
computer programs and to establish himself as THE CONTENDER.

Obviously, Mr. Hsu did not like my answers very much, became belligerent and
made threats and even grandly imposed deadlines.

On Dec. 3rd, amongst other things, I repeated to him:

"Your tone is quite hostile and with angry people, I like to keep my   responses
simple.  Garry remains ready, willing and able to play a serious match against a
computer - under the right conditions."

So persistent did Mr. Hsu become that on Dec. 21s I wrote to him:

"He (Kasparov) will not be associated with an open letter like this. It is not
the way he does business and it would run counter to discussions he is having
with others."

The next day Mr. Hsu sent a draft letter intended to go out openly soliciting
sponsors on his and Garry's behalf!

On Dec. 23rd, I replied as follows:

 "I think that maybe I am not expressing myself very clearly. Mr. Kasparov does
not authorize you to say anything at all. I hope this is very clear."

Incredibly, Mr. Hsu wrote once again, wanting Garry's authorization for another
letter.

My last e-mail (in exasperation) was:

"You continue making statements which are your words and not Garry's. Please
read what I have sent you very carefully."

Effectively, Mr. Hsu had many strikes against him:

* He behaved as if he was Deep Blue and we know he is not.

* All he had was a computer chip with no organization or sponsor behind him.

* Garry made it very clear that he was not going to give him time just to go on
a "fishing trip" for a year or two to try and attract sponsors or money.

* His entire presentation was speculative and without substance.

* He began almost immediately to make threats and he seemed to think, like many
before him, that all he had to do to get Garry to do his bidding, was to
threaten "exposure."

* To summarize, he had no sponsor, no money, no entity and was entirely lacking
in any seriousness or credibility from a business point of view.

Ironically, Mr. Hsu waited until two and a half years after the match to set up
a flurry of e-mails which almost from the beginning were threatening in nature.
On reflection, I firmly believe that he knew his offer had no credibility and he
was looking for a little publicity and some notoriety.

For any of you who still think Mr. Hsu was above-board, just put yourself in his
position.  Would you not have called up and said, "Hsu here.  Let's put our
heads together and see if we can make this thing work."

That's not a good idea if all you want out of this is to have a go at THE WORLD
CHAMPION!

Owen Williams

S.M.S.I. Inc., Palm Beach, FL.



This page took 0.03 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.