Computer Chess Club Archives

Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Shredder in the SSDF list

Author: Frederic Friedel

Date: 13:52:13 04/12/00

>I think it comes down to my feeling that SSDF exists best as an independent
>organization, like e.g. Consumer Reports.  If you start picking sides to favour
>or disfavour somebody, that brings into question the legitimacy of your list.
>Instead, publish everything you're allowed to... and this now includes a rating
>for Shredder 4.


Does Consumer Reports have to get permission from the manufacturers of each
product whether it can be tested or not? Can and has a manufactuere successfully
instructed Consumer Reports not to publish the results of a test? How exactly
can you aim to be "independent" if you have to abide by such instructions?

Just curious to know.

Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Thorsten Czub 10:28:45 04/13/00
- Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Enrique Irazoqui 10:38:33 04/13/00
  - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Thorsten Czub 05:10:36 04/14/00
    - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Tom Kerrigan 09:05:20 04/14/00
Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Dave Gomboc 18:56:06 04/12/00
- Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Thorsten Czub 10:37:13 04/13/00
  - Baseless accusations Dave Gomboc 18:09:45 04/15/00
    - Re: Baseless accusations Bertil Eklund 13:25:06 04/16/00
      - Re: Baseless accusations Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 03:40:33 04/17/00
        
        Moderation: Re: Baseless accusations Andrew Williams 05:09:46 04/17/00
        
        Re: Baseless accusations blass uri 04:35:45 04/17/00
        
        Re: Baseless accusations blass uri 04:41:37 04/17/00
      - Re: Baseless accusations Djordje Vidanovic 18:16:02 04/16/00
        
        Re: Baseless accusations blass uri 20:15:58 04/16/00
  - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list blass uri 14:21:26 04/13/00
    - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 03:01:30 04/14/00
      - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Bertil Eklund 06:39:16 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 07:57:27 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Ritter Rost 08:10:14 04/15/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 09:44:14 04/15/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Ritter Rost 11:59:03 04/15/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 04:35:15 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Bertil Eklund 09:46:43 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 09:54:59 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Tony Hedlund 10:59:26 04/15/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 04:38:23 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Robert Hyatt 20:22:47 04/15/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Jason Williamson 01:33:18 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Robert Hyatt 07:05:45 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Enrique Irazoqui 07:11:13 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Robert Hyatt 10:25:20 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Dave Gomboc 08:42:12 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Enrique Irazoqui 11:04:26 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Robert Hyatt 10:30:47 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Paulo Soares 13:07:31 04/16/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Ernst Walet 03:22:11 04/16/00
      - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list blass uri 04:51:51 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Bertil Eklund 06:50:19 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list blass uri 07:42:12 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 08:01:34 04/14/00
- Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Frederic Friedel 02:40:00 04/13/00
  - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Thorsten Czub 10:41:41 04/13/00
    - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Jason Williamson 21:48:30 04/13/00
      - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Stefan Meyer-Kahlen 09:57:14 04/14/00
      - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Harald Faber 09:36:34 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Tom Kerrigan 10:18:29 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Harald Faber 06:48:07 04/15/00
      - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Tina Long 23:25:37 04/13/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Ed Schröder 03:20:26 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list blass uri 02:47:18 04/14/00
        
        Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Bertil Eklund 02:59:08 04/14/00
    - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Tony Hedlund 11:17:16 04/13/00
      - Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Thorsten Czub 05:21:53 04/14/00
Re: Shredder in the SSDF list Bertil Eklund 14:25:23 04/12/00

This page took 0.02 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.