Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Man vs Machine Rating list 17Jul, 2000 (175 games)

Author: Peter Kappler

Date: 15:51:46 07/19/00

Go up one level in this thread


On July 19, 2000 at 18:17:48, Vincent Diepeveen wrote:

>On July 19, 2000 at 10:38:50, Chris Carson wrote:
>
>>Man vs Machine       17 Jul, 2000
>>
>>Notes:
>>This is a composite list of TPR's plus other published
>>rated games.
>>PR=Provisional Rating.
>>All games are 40/2.
>>At least 4 games are required to be listed.
>>PR = OPP FIDE Avg + 400(w-l)/Tot
>>FIDE defines GM level as 2500 and higher
>>FIDE defines IM level as 2400 and higher
>>Ref: http://www.uschess.org/
>>     http://www.fide.org/
>>2 games from Dutch Championship not included due to forfit.
>>The error of measure is aprox. 75 points.
>>S/W		Mp    	MHZ 	PR	Opp	W	D	L	Tot
>>97Deep Blue	multi		2862	2795	2	3	1	6
>>DJ 6		P3- 8x	700	2702	2702	2	5	2	9
>>P. ConNerS	P2-32x	300	2663	2518	6	3	2	11
>>96Deep Blue	multi		2642	2775	1	2	3	6
>>Fritz 6/SSS	P3- 4x	500	2635	2555	4	4	2	10
>
>10 games you count here for fritz. at dutch championship there were 10
>games indeed, but one game was resigned after 2 moves by IM bosboom.
>the 11th game was of course a forfeit of v/d sterren by not wanting to
>play fritz at all.
>

The Bosboom and Van der Sterren games should definitely not count.  There was
some discussion about this, and I thought Chris finally agreed not to count
those games.


>So i'm amazed you have counted a total of 10 games here.
>
>I can't get to 10. I can only get to 9.
>
>Then if we also count the huge time trouble problem from Herman Grooten,
>who was dead won but lost in time trouble, then we have 8 games.
>
>Also Tiviakov complained that at the sudden death level he would not have
>drawn if the last time controls would have given him more time to win the
>endgame, where he now drew it because of the time trouble.
>

These games should be counted.

The time control should be noted, because sudden death time controls put the
human at a disadvantage, but to not count the games at all would be silly.

--Peter




This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.