Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: WMCCC pairings round 5 not in accordance with swiss system rules!

Author: pete

Date: 10:35:35 08/23/00

Go up one level in this thread


On August 22, 2000 at 17:05:34, Sylvain Renard wrote:

>Hello,
>if results are correct, there is a problem with the
>pairings of round 5.
>First 3 are correct (Shredder-Junior, Rebel-Fritz and Nimzo- Chess Tiger)
>But then Crafty, ZChess and SOS have 2 points.
>Crafty has already played against ZChess.
>Zchess have to play with White (he had black in rounds 3 and 4)
>SOS should play with Black (he had white in round 4)
>Can someone explain to my why the pairing is not ZCHESS - SOS ???
>
>  Sylvain Renard (official arbiter of the french chess federation)

Swissperfect usually does quite ok pairing but to my experience sometimes has
problems with the even rounds .

I really wish someone tells the organizers to re-pair the 6th round as the
pairings are not only illegal but more important really have the potential to
scew the final out-come very much .

I don't think this will happen though :-(

It seems most Swiss software is far away from perfection still . Ie for the
final round of cct-1 on ICC Nordicswiss ( not completely sure about the name )
was used and it would have paired completely illegal and this would have changed
the outcome too ( for example Bringer would have got tcsp :-) as opponent which
was about 3 points difference in pairing in a 9 round swiss ) .

Fortunately SJLIM ( dunno right name ), the referee made a manual repairing
which was perfectly ok .

But Swissperfect seems to be one of the better ones you get free trial on .

pete



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.