Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Bob's Fourm or Robert's Forum

Author: Bruce Moreland

Date: 09:43:13 10/06/00

Go up one level in this thread


On October 06, 2000 at 08:10:24, Peter Davison wrote:

>On October 06, 2000 at 07:57:36, Timothy J. Frohlick wrote:
>
>>This is not Bob's Forum--It belongs to Mr. Steve Schwartz.
>
>Contrary to popular opinion, this is not true. Mr Schwartz *hosts* the forum,
>and his company has rights to the software on which it runs.
>
>The *ownership* of the forum, the forum name, the idea, is vested in a group of
>10 known as the Founder's Group. This ownership has never been passed to ICD.
>The Founder's Group passed the moderation function to a elective moderation
>process, but they did not pass any ownership away. Theoretically the Founders
>Group, if they were talking to each other, could reform, take on an oversee
>function of the moderators, start the board up on another site or whatever.

You've never been a moderator, so you haven't seen how things work these days.
Steve will stay out of moderation issues to a large degree, but when he feels
that things are getting silly, or that his business or reputation is in
jeopardy, he will step in.  He stepped in pretty seriously between my last term
and the one following it, he used the period of transition to make a few rules.
It wasn't the moderators who decreed that you now have to sign up here with your
real name.

There are even some moderation issues that fit into a gray area between Steve
and the Moderators.  For instance, this is Steve's *site*, and Steve has the
right to protect his site.  In my last term, Steve felt that a member was
attacking his site, so he blocked that member's IP address.

This is Steve's board.

The current battle is about peope with hurt feelings about stuff that CCC
moderation didn't even have much to do with Bob.  Bob turned off a thread.  Big
fucking deal.

People are calling for a revolution against -- what exactly?

People who are into this controversy solely because they want to express their
antibobism, should remember that Bob is here as the result of an election, and
that he's one of three in charge, and presumably they have their own process
such that Bob either represents them has been given freedom to moderate by them,
and that regardless of what is going on it will only last until the end of
January.

bruce


>> You are here because
>>of the courtesy of Mr. Schwartz to allow you to be here.
>>
>
>Mr Schwartz has an executive power since he currently controls the on/off
>switch. But be clear, it is an executive power, not a political one, and not
>based on ownership of the forum.
>
>Mr Schwartz was *not* a member of the Founder Group, btw. He asked, via Enrique
>Irazoqui, to be allowed to be on it, but this request was turned down.
>
>
>
>>
>>Tim Frohlick



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.