Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: A comment :o).

Author: Sune Larsson

Date: 03:40:26 10/14/00

Go up one level in this thread


On October 14, 2000 at 06:00:33, Mogens Larsen wrote:

>The match is certainly very interesting and it suggests that the Tiger 13.0 beta
>is a very strong engine. Not a big surprise considering the amount of successful
>games posted here recently. The same naturally goes for Gambit Tiger.
>Congratulations to Christophe Theron for that achievement.
>
>However, I do find the exchange afterwards slightly dubious from the perspective
>of objective information. Especially since everyone, except Jorge Pichard, are
>Rebel beta testers by own admisson. Don't you have a mailing list or something
>similar where you can share your feelings, impressions and general well-being?
>
>This thread, and other similar "private" discussions among Rebel beta testers
>here, is borderline commercial exhortation IMO. Bombarding the unsuspecting
>consumer with biased comments én masse seem to be the intention. The Sune
>Larsson post gives the impression that he's an average consumer when he's
>actually a betatester as well, judging from previous messages here. I presume he
>already knows what games Chris has or hasn't played. Rather blatant to some and,
>excuse my language, slightly pathetic.



 Yes Mogens, you really seem to "presume" lots of things about other people...
 Opinions regarding what is "best" for others, what others should do or not do
 seem to be one of your favourite occupations. Well, that can be a life also,
 I suppose. In this special case, with the Tiger-Shredder games played by
 Chris, I actually haven't seen them posted anywhere else. So, these games
 were news to me, copied them from this place and went through them all.
 The same to me if Shredder had won the match with 13-2. In that case I would
 have posted my excitement concerning Shredder... It's simply interesting, at
 least for me, when one top program can beat the other in such a spectacular
 way. So it seems your words "blatant" and "slightly pathetic" just backfire
 to yourself...

 Sune
>
>So instead of adding subjective comments, it would be preferable if you just
>posted games and answered questions and comments from potential customers.
>Starting threads with "spontaneous" comments and patting each others backs until
>your hands are sore seem slightly ridiculous. Letting the members of this forum
>judge for themselves without staged commentary seem fairer.
>
>That just my opinion.
>
>Mogens.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.