Author: Bruce Moreland
Date: 17:13:28 11/20/00
Go up one level in this thread
You have to deal with this even if you don't bring theology (or free will versus determinism, which isn't dependent upon theologoy, I think) into it. The game of chess is computable, it is possible to devise an algorithm that will prove the correct result for any specific position. The only limitation is time of execution. So, when you make your move, you have to deal with the idea that there are one or more best moves in a given position, and it is possible in theory to know for a fact what they are. This wouldn't stop me from playing chess, I can't understand why it would stop anyone from playing chess. bruce On November 20, 2000 at 01:02:24, Timothy J. Frohlick wrote: >Mr. Chen, > >This is a very interesting philosophical question. If God plays with the >universe as a game and God has perfect knowledge then what is the point of >playing. A being that knows the beginning and the end outcome would certainly >have no motive for playing the game. > >By saying that God does not exist, you obviate this quandary. On the other >hand, eliminating the "First Cause" poses its' own set of problems. We must >therefore say that the existance of the game is sufficient in itself. The game >is subsumed under the contents of the universe. The game IS. > >Chess will not die if the outcome of it is always certain. The game IS. > > >Tim Frohlick > >Yes, there will come a time when the chess >>engine will play perfect chess, when that time comes it will certainly be the >>death of chess. Why would anyone want to play the game, if a machine is capable >>of playing flawless chess to a perfection. Which human wouldn't use the >>machine, and all the games would end up in a draw. So what is the point of >>reaching chess perfection? If reaching this perfection will bring the game to >>its doomsday!!! My two cents worth. >>Laurence
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.