Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: More ECM Inconsistencies (#001 - #099)

Author: Ernst A. Heinz

Date: 05:48:08 01/22/98

Go up one level in this thread


On January 22, 1998 at 07:30:35, Amir Ban wrote:

>>>ECM #031
>>>original solution  = [ Nxd4 ]
>>>"DarkThought" says = [ Rd6, Qd5, Qa6, h6, h5, Kh8 ] are equally good
>>>                     (score = 0.8 after iteration #13)
>
>Disagree. Nxd4 takes a pawn safely and simplifies into an endgame with a
>pawn up. You are evaluating the position as already +1 for black but I
>don't know if everyone will agree with that.

No, "DarkThought" thinks it gets the weak pawn on d4 anyway -- until
iteration #11 it also prefers Nxd4 but then fails low on it to +0.65.

>>>ECM #070
>>>original solution  = [ e4 ]
>>>"DarkThought" says = [ Rf3 ] Kh1 g5 d4 exd4 Re6 Qg7 ...
>>>                             (score = +1 after iteration #13,
>>>                              g5 directly seems to be a transposition)
>
>I tend to disagree. e4 is positional, and the point is that it's
>possible. It prepares a pawn storm through d5, g5 and eventually e3, but
>white is not dead yet. Rf3 doesn't seem to do much.

Rf3 fixes the white f-pawn on f2, thus preventing White from advancing
it.
"DarkThought" thinks that the E file will be opened anyway -- in its PV
White plays d4 and then Black takes exd4.

>>>ECM #075
>>>original solution  = [ Nh6 ]
>>>"DarkThought" says = [ Qh4, g6 ] are also good
>>>                     (score = 1.2 after iteration #13)
>>>
>
>Nh6 takes a pawn and opens up things. I am not able to look so deep at
>your alternatives, but seems to me that black keeps material balance and
>holds with Rd7 for both.

"DarkThought" thinks it gets at least a pawn in all these cases ...

=Ernst=



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.