Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Thanks. I think 16.Nd3+ is the best move

Author: Eduard Nemeth

Date: 21:22:42 01/16/01

Go up one level in this thread


On January 16, 2001 at 22:44:38, Pete Galati wrote:

>On January 16, 2001 at 19:30:17, Pete Galati wrote:
>
>>On January 16, 2001 at 19:21:11, Eduard Nemeth wrote:
>>
>>>On January 16, 2001 at 16:59:55, Pete Galati wrote:
>>>
>>>>On January 16, 2001 at 15:06:10, Eduard Nemeth wrote:
>>>>
>>>>>Morozevich played strong 16...Nd3+!
>>>>>
>>>>>What chess program played this move ?
>>>>>
>>>>>[Event "Corus Wijk aan Zee NED "]
>>>>>[Site "?"]
>>>>>[Date "2001.??.??"]
>>>>>[Round "3"]
>>>>>[White "Van Wely,L"]
>>>>>[Black "Morozevich,A"]
>>>>>[WhiteElo "2700"]
>>>>>[BlackElo "2745"]
>>>>>[ECO "D16"]
>>>>>[Result "0-1"]
>>>>>
>>>>>1. d4 d5 2. c4 c6 3. Nf3 Nf6 4. Nc3 dxc4 5. a4 c5 6. d5 Bf5
>>>>>7. e3 e6 8. Bxc4 exd5 9. Nxd5 Nc6 10. Qb3 Qd7 11. Nxf6+
>>>>>gxf6 12. Bd2 Rg8 13. Bc3 O-O-O 14. Bxf7 Rxg2 15. Nh4 Ne5
>>>>>16. Nxf5 Nd3+ 17. Kf1 Rxf2+ 18. Kg1 Kb8 19. Qe6 Rxf5 20. h4
>>>>>Bd6 21. Rf1 Rg8+ 0-1
>>>>>
>>>>>FEN:
>>>>>
>>>>>[D]2kr1b2/pp1q1B1p/5p2/2p1nN2/P7/1QB1P3/1P3PrP/R3K2R b KQ - 0 16
>>>>>
>>>>>Eduard
>>[......]
>>>Hello!
>>>
>>>Thanks, too all my programs don't find this move 16.Nd3+! in 30 minutes. :)
>>>
>>>But i think, that is the best move in this position!
>>>
>>>My analysis with "Fritz 6a" in this position, after 16.Nd3+ say this:
>>>after 19.Qe6 it was a lost position for Van Wely!
>>>
>>>But after 19.Ng3 ist the position too lost!
>>>19.Ng3 Qc6! 20.e4 c4! and the position ist lost for white (Fritz6)!
>>>
>>>Give ask your program the position new after the move 18...Kb8 (or 19.Ng3)and
>>>you will it see.
>>>
>>>Regards,
>>>Eduard
>>
>>[D]1k1r1b2/pp1q1B1p/5p2/2p2N2/P7/1QBnP3/1P3r1P/R5KR w - - 0 19
>>
>>Ok, this is after Kb8.  I should be back around 8PM Chicago time.
>>
>>Pete

Hello!

Sorry, my english speak is poor, and i do not all that (what you say)
understand!

>
>I'm late, took me longer than I expected.
>

Comet B28 is, i belive a Beta-Version. I have only a Comet B11 version
from Fritz. This Beta-version i can download from Frank Quisinsky's News Ticker.

I have belived Comet B28 are stronger! But i see, it is not also, or ?

After Kb8 and 7:46 minutes, Fritz6 score are - 1.84 (after 30', -2.41 on a P600)

Here a first analysis with a the NEW Engine from Fritz6 (2000.12.16):
Analysis by Fritz 6 ("new update" from the english ChessBase webside):

19.Sg3 Dc6 20.e4 c4 21.Dxc4 Db6 22.Ld4 Txd4 23.Db5 Dxb5
  µ  (-1.34)   deep: 12/34   00:00:45  21551kN
19.Sg3 Dc6 20.e4 c4 21.Db5 Lc5 22.Dxc6 bxc6 23.Lxc4 Txb2+
  -+  (-1.44)   deep: 13/32   00:02:31  71769kN
19.Sg3--
  -+  (-1.75)   deep: 14/32   00:04:52  137909kN
19.Sg3 Dc6 20.e4 c4 21.Dxc4 Db6 22.La5 Dxa5 23.b4 Lxb4
  -+  (-1.84)   deep: 14/38   00:07:46  222851kN

I Think, after Kb8 are Ng3 the best move for white, but the position is
complete higher looser, then after 16.Nxf7!

I have thinking that Comet B28 is little big better (I know, Comet is a
program from Ulrich Tuerke)! I am not contendet with the analysis from
Comet B28 !

Thank You anyway for this analysis from Comet B28!!

Kind Regards,
Eduard

>Comet didn't want Qe6, it seemed intent on Ng3.  Just to be clear about this,
>Comet is not MY program, it's Uli Türke's program.  I just tend to analyze games
>with it because I've developed a liking to the program and it's interface.  I
>don't want to get more credit than I deserve on this one.
>
>Pete
>
>Comet-B.28    Tue Jan 16 18:37:24 2001
>
>depth	score	  sec	  nodes		  pv
> 1.	+2.38	    0	      830	 f7e6
> 2.	+1.53	    0	     1528	 e3e4  d7c6
> 3.	+2.10	    0	     4150	 e3e4  f8e7  b3e6
> 4.	+1.99	    0	    21131	 e3e4  f8g7  b3e6  d3f4
> 4.	+1.99	    0	    37390	 e3e4  f8g7  b3e6  d3f4
> 5.	+2.26	    0	   110968	 e3e4  f2f5  e4f5  d7f5  b3c2  f8d6
> 5.	+2.26	    0	   131616	 e3e4  f2f5  e4f5  d7f5  b3c2  f8d6
> 6?	+2.12	    1	   181182	 e3e4  f8g7  b3b7  d7b7  f5g7
> 6?	+1.85	    1	   268868	 e3e4  f8g7  b3b7  d7b7  f5g7
> 6!	+1.85	    2	   448843	 e3e4  f8g7
> 6.	+1.85	    2	   448843	 e3e4  f8g7
> 7?	+1.71	    4	   827159	 e3e4  c5c4  b3c4  f2f5  f7d5  f5d5  c4d5
> 7?	+1.44	    7	  1439715	 e3e4  c5c4  f7c4  f8c5  f5g3  d3b2  a1a2
> 7?	+1.17	   10	  1890278	 e3e4  c5c4  f7c4  f8c5  c3e5  f6e5
> 7?	+0.90	   14	  2792997	 e3e4  c5c4  f7c4  f8c5  f5h4  d3b2  e4e5
> 7?	+0.63	   18	  3680763	 e3e4  c5c4  f7c4  f8c5  f5h6  d3b2  b3c2
> 7?	+0.36	   24	  5224696	 e3e4  c5c4  b3c4  f8c5  e4e5  f6e5  c4d4
> 7.	+0.59	   28	  6084836	 f5g3  f8h6  b3e6  h6e3  e6e3  d7f7  a1d1
> 7.	+0.59	   28	  6166358	 f5g3  f8h6  b3e6  h6e3  e6e3  d7f7  a1d1
> 8!	+0.72	   34	  7611924	 f5g3  f8h6  b3e6  h6e3  e6e3  d7f7  a1d1
> 8?	+0.72	   36	  7949534	 f5g3  f8d6  c3f6  f2f6  b3b7  d7b7  f7e6
> 8.	+0.72	   46	 10363071	 f5g3  f8d6  c3f6  f2f6  b3b7  d7b7  f7e6
> 9?	+0.58	   56	 13134882	 f5g3  f8d6  c3f6  f2f6  b3d3  f6f7  d3h7
> 9?	+0.31	   94	 23376016	 f5g3  f8d6  c3f6  f2f6  b3d3  f6f7  d3h7
> 9?	+0.04	  121	 30756688	 f5g3  f8d6  c3f6  f2f6  b3d3  f6f7  d3h7
> 9?	-0.23	  165	 44512695	 f5g3  f8d6  c3f6  f2f6  b3d3
> 9!	-0.23	  223	 62770476	 f5g3  f8d6  b3e6  d7c7  e6h3  d3b2
> 9.	-0.23	  223	 62770476	 f5g3  f8d6  b3e6  d7c7  e6h3  d3b2
>10.	-0.21	  290	 82858726	 f5g3  f8h6  b3e6  d7e6  f7e6  h6e3  g3f1
>10.	-0.21	  386	108073434	 f5g3  f8h6  b3e6  d7e6  f7e6  h6e3  g3f1
>11?	-0.35	  481	138784103	 f5g3  f8h6  b3e6  d7e6  f7e6  h6e3  g3f1
>11?	-0.62	  869	261324327	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3c4  c6b6  a4a5
>11.	-0.71	 1242	383325318	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3b5  c6b5  a4b5
>11.	-0.71	 1375	424360851	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3b5  c6b5  a4b5
>12?	-0.85	 1453	450307183	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3b5  c6c7  f7c4
>12!	-0.85	 3360	1079437865	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3b5  c6c7  b5a5
>12.	-0.85	 3360	1079437865	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3b5  c6c7  b5a5
>13?	-0.99	 3648	1173666401	 f5g3  d7c6  e3e4  c5c4  b3b5  c6c5  b5c5
>13?	-1.26	10026	-975100820	 f5g3  d7c6  b3b7  c6b7  c3f6
>13.	-1.26	10039	-970605180	 f5g3  d7c6  b3b7  c6b7  c3f6
>
>==> My Move: f5g3 in 167:19










This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.