Author: Eduard Nemeth
Date: 15:22:41 02/16/01
By Week in Chess I find Enriques Tournament, and this incorrect game:
[Event "Computer Chess Match Tournament (1) ;The Week in Chess 327"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "2001.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Deep Fritz"]
[Black "Gambit Tiger 1.0"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "D97"]
1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 d5 4. Nf3 Bg7 5. Qb3 dxc4 6. Qxc4 O-O 7. e4 Na6 8.
Be2 c5 9. d5 e6 10. O-O exd5 11. exd5 Bf5 12. Bf4 Qb6 13. Be5 Rad8 14. d6 Nd7
15. Bxg7 Kxg7 16. Nb5 Nf6 17. a4 Nb8 18. b4 cxb4 19. a5 Qc6 20. Qxb4 Qe4 21.
Qd2 Qc2 22. Qxc2 Bxc2 23. Rfc1 Be4 24. Rd1 a6 25. Nc7 Nc6 26. Ng5 Bc2 27. Nxf7
Rxf7 28. Ne6+ Kh6 29. Nxd8 Nxd8 30. Rd2 Bf5 31. Rc1 Ne4 32. Rd4 Nc6 33. Rdd1
Rd7 34. g4 Be6 35. Bf3 Ng5 36. Bxc6 bxc6 37. Rxc6 Bxg4 38. Rdc1 Be2 39. Rb6
Nh3+ 40. Kg2 Nf4+ 41. Kg1 Nd5 42. Rb2 Bb5 43. Rd2 Nf4 44. Rcd1 Kg5 45. f3 Kf6
46. Kf2 Ne6 47. h4 Ng7 48. Rc2 Nf5 49. Rc7 Ke6 50. Rxd7 Bxd7 51. f4 Nxd6 52.
Re1+ Kf6 53. Rd1 Ke7 54. Re1+ Kd8 55. Rb1 Bb5 56. Re1 Nf5 57. Rg1 Ng7 58. Re1
Kd7 59. Kf3 h5 60. Kg2 Kd6 61. Kh2 Kd5 62. Rg1 Bd3 63. Rg2 Ne6 64. Kg3 Ke4 65.
Rg1 Nxf4 66. Kh2 Kd4 67. Rc1 Ne6 68. Kg3 Nc5 69. Ra1 Nb3 70. Ra2 Kc4 71. Kf2
Kb4 72. Ke3 Bf5 73. Kf4 Nxa5 74. Kg5 Bd3 75. Rd2 Kc3 76. Ra2 Nb3 77. Kf6 a5
78. Ra4 Bb5 79. Ra2 a4 80. Kxg6 Nc1 81. Ra3+ Kb4 82. Ra1 Nb3 83. Ra2 Be8+ 84.
Kg5 Nd4 85. Rb2+ Kc3 86. Rb8 Bc6 87. Rb6 a3 88. Ra6 Kb3 89. Ra7 a2 90. Rxa2
Kxa2 91. Kxh5 Bd7 92. Kg6 Nf3 93. h5 Be8+ 94. Kh6 Kb2 95. Kg7 Bxh5 96. Kf6 Bg4
97. Ke7 Kc3 98. Kf7 Kd4 99. Kf6 Kd5 100. Kf7 Kd6 101. Kf6 Be6 102. Kg7 Ke7
103. Kg6 Bg4 104. Kh7 Kf6 105. Kg8 Nd4 106. Kh7 Bf3 107. Kg8 Be4 108. Kh8 Nc6
109. Kg8 Nd8 110. Kf8 Ne6+ 111. Kg8 Kg6 112. Kh8 Bf3 113. Kg8 Bg2 114. Kh8 Bd5
115. Kg8 Bc6 116. Kh8 Nf4 117. Kg8 Nd5 118. Kh8 Nb4 119. Kg8 Bd5+ 120. Kh8 Kf6
121. Kh7 Nc6 122. Kh8 Ne5 123. Kh7 Bf3 124. Kg8 Nc6 125. Kh7 Ne7 126. Kh8 Nf5
127. Kg8 Kg6 128. Kh8 Kf7 129. Kh7 Bd5 130. Kh8 Nd4 131. Kh7 Nf3 132. Kh8 Kf6
133. Kh7 Nd4 134. Kh8 Be4 135. Kg8 Ne6 136. Kh8 Bd5 137. Kh7 Ng5+ 138. Kh8 Ke7
139. Kg7 Be4 140. Kg8 Ke6 141. Kg7 Bf5 142. Kg8 Kf6 143. Kh8 Nf3 144. Kg8 Ne5
145. Kh8 1/2-1/2
My opinion is: this game and notation is not correct!
Here my answer for Enrique Irazoqui:
Hi Enrique,
Thanx to M. Scheidl I now have the trnslation of your posting, as you can see
via the quoted game annotation.
Why was the game declared as a draw ? As one can easily see in the PGN
annotation below, DF would have had to resign exactly after 3 times minus 6.5.
Quite obvius that you know this too - and I also have critisized it quite
clearly that GT is unable to acchieve a mate with B + N !
In case DF has finally resigned in move 91 it's more or less a shame in this
case, alas : a resign remains resign - therefore the result must be o-1 and
surelly not 1/2.
As far as I could detect it's probably your own fault here, because you didn't
set DF to "never resign " and, because of this, continued this game. It sure may
be fun to watch a prog that's unable to solve a position correct, while the
other one allready shows the upcoming mate in it's own evaluation.
For my personal opionion, it should be of importance ore relevance :
1. What's marked 1stly, has to be respected - and this was a "resign" of DF !
2. On the other hand, as allready mentioned, one sure can have his personal
entertainment to watch one prog resign while the other one doesn't even know,
what's going on.
So, quite obvious :
as done, this game should have been finished maually but the result, of course,
coudln't be anything else than a 0-1.
This is, BTW, my opinion and I sure would have acted likewise as a principle.
Here the correct notation + result (by Enrique!):
[Event "40'/40+40'/40+40'40/Dual P933"]
[Site "Cadaqués"]
[Date "2001.01.28"]
[Round "1"]
[White "DEEP FRITZ"]
[Black "Gambit Tiger 1.0"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "D97"]
[Annotator "0.47"]
[PlyCount "182"]
[EventDate "2001.01.04"]
{256MB, DeepFritz.ctg. Dual P933
} 1. d4 {0} 1... Nf6 {1} 2. c4 {0} 2... g6 {1
} 3. Nc3 {0} 3... d5 {0} 4. Nf3 {0} 4... Bg7 {1} 5. Qb3 {0} 5... dxc4 {1} 6.
Qxc4 {0} 6... O-O {1} 7. e4 {0} 7... Na6 {1} 8. Be2 {0} 8... c5 {1} 9. d5 {0}
9... e6 {1} 10. O-O {0} 10... exd5 {1} 11. exd5 {0} 11... Bf5 {1} 12. Bf4 {0}
12... Qb6 {1} 13. Be5 {0} 13... Rad8 {0} 14. d6 {0} 14... Nd7 {1} 15. Bxg7 {0}
15... Kxg7 {1} 16. Nb5 {0} 16... Nf6 {1} 17. a4 {last book move 0.47/13 101}
17... Nb8 {180} 18. b4 {0.75/12 69} 18... cxb4 {96} 19. a5 {0.72/14 0} 19...
Qc6 {173} 20. Qxb4 {0.84/14 0} 20... Qe4 {87} 21. Qd2 {0.69/12 92} 21... Qc2 {
40} 22. Qxc2 {0.53/13 130} 22... Bxc2 {11} 23. Rfc1 {0.56/13 107} 23... Be4 {39
} 24. Rd1 {0.63/13 82} 24... a6 {114} 25. Nc7 {0.47/14 3} 25... Nc6 {143} 26.
Ng5 {0.47/14 0} 26... Bc2 {138} 27. Nxf7 {0.41/15 0} 27... Rxf7 {95} 28. Ne6+ {
0.31/15 0} 28... Kh6 {102} 29. Nxd8 {0.16/15 0} 29... Nxd8 {27} 30. Rd2 {
-0.03/15 143} 30... Bf5 {1} 31. Rc1 {0.00/14 171} 31... Ne4 {163} 32. Rd4 {
-0.25/14 127} 32... Nc6 {152} 33. Rdd1 {0.03/15 195} 33... Rd7 {84} 34. g4 {
0.00/16 207} 34... Be6 {123} 35. Bf3 {0.00/16 0} 35... Ng5 {92} 36. Bxc6 {
0.00/16 0} 36... bxc6 {12} 37. Rxc6 {0.00/15 45} 37... Bxg4 {140} 38. Rdc1 {
-0.25/15 0} 38... Be2 {123} 39. Rb6 {-0.47/15 0} 39... Nh3+ {136} 40. Kg2 {
-0.56/18 0} 40... Nf4+ {136} 41. Kg1 {-0.53/18 0} 41... Nd5 {52} 42. Rb2 {
-0.59/17 50} 42... Bb5 {53} 43. Rd2 {-0.84/16 72} 43... Nf4 {1} 44. Rcd1 {
-0.69/15 58} 44... Kg5 {139} 45. f3 {-1.06/16 0} 45... Kf6 {69} 46. Kf2 {
-1.22/16 34} 46... Ne6 {49} 47. h4 {-1.31/16 96} 47... Ng7 {78} 48. Rc2 {
-1.59/17 127} 48... Nf5 {54} 49. Rc7 {-1.56/17 72} 49... Ke6 {1} 50. Rxd7 {
-1.59/16 93} 50... Bxd7 {229} 51. f4 {-1.62/18 0} 51... Nxd6 {51} 52. Re1+ {
-1.69/16 23} 52... Kf6 {32} 53. Rd1 {-1.72/16 39} 53... Ke7 {46} 54. Re1+ {
-1.72/15 46} 54... Kd8 {77} 55. Rb1 {-1.75/16 1} 55... Bb5 {76} 56. Re1 {
-1.72/16 38} 56... Nf5 {16} 57. Rg1 {-1.72/17 121} 57... Ng7 {1} 58. Re1 {
-1.75/16 79} 58... Kd7 {8} 59. Kf3 {-1.81/16 160} 59... h5 {60} 60. Kg2 {
-2.09/17 78} 60... Kd6 {60} 61. Kh2 {-2.37/18 127} 61... Kd5 {65} 62. Rg1 {
-2.47/18 104} 62... Bd3 {1} 63. Rg2 {-2.56/18 96} 63... Ne6 {87} 64. Kg3 {
-2.66/18 14} 64... Ke4 {62} 65. Rg1 {-2.72/18 52} 65... Nxf4 {62} 66. Kh2 {
-2.81/17 33} 66... Kd4 {63} 67. Rc1 {-3.22/19 209} 67... Ne6 {62} 68. Kg3 {
-3.28/18 32} 68... Nc5 {29} 69. Ra1 {-3.44/18 64} 69... Nb3 {1} 70. Ra2 {
-3.62/19 139} 70... Kc4 {1} 71. Kf2 {-3.69/19 132} 71... Kb4 {150} 72. Ke3 {
-3.87/21 0} 72... Bf5 {68} 73. Kf4 {-3.94/19 31} 73... Nxa5 {65} 74. Kg5 {
-4.03/19 77} 74... Bd3 {69} 75. Rd2 {-4.47/20 173} 75... Kc3 {1} 76. Ra2 {
-4.25/18 45} 76... Nb3 {35} 77. Kf6 {-4.53/17 29} 77... a5 {88} 78. Ra4 {
-4.87/17 68} 78... Bb5 {110} 79. Ra2 {-4.75/19 0} 79... a4 {123} 80. Kxg6 {
-4.75/18 36} 80... Nc1 {87} 81. Ra3+ {-4.69/18 71} 81... Kb4 {118} 82. Ra1 {
-4.53/18 85} 82... Nb3 {143} 83. Ra2 {-4.75/18 0} 83... Be8+ {58} 84. Kg5 {
-4.72/18 0} 84... Nd4 {135} 85. Rb2+ {-4.84/18 0} 85... Kc3 {79} 86. Rb8 {
-4.94/18 0} 86... Bc6 {81} 87. Rb6 {-4.87/17 0} 87... a3 {52} 88. Ra6 {
-6.00/16 60} 88... Kb3 {161} 89. Ra7 {-8.47/17 0} 89... a2 {49} 90. Rxa2 {
-8.12/18 72} 90... Kxa2 {0} 91. Kxh5 {-13.47/19 72} 91... Bd7 {Resigns 0} 0-1
Regards,
Eduard
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.