Author: Bertil Eklund
Date: 16:15:15 02/16/01
Go up one level in this thread
On February 16, 2001 at 18:22:41, Eduard Nemeth wrote:
>By Week in Chess I find Enriques Tournament, and this incorrect game:
>
>[Event "Computer Chess Match Tournament (1) ;The Week in Chess 327"]
>[Site "?"]
>[Date "2001.??.??"]
>[Round "?"]
>[White "Deep Fritz"]
>[Black "Gambit Tiger 1.0"]
>[Result "1/2-1/2"]
>[ECO "D97"]
>
>1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 d5 4. Nf3 Bg7 5. Qb3 dxc4 6. Qxc4 O-O 7. e4 Na6 8.
>Be2 c5 9. d5 e6 10. O-O exd5 11. exd5 Bf5 12. Bf4 Qb6 13. Be5 Rad8 14. d6 Nd7
>15. Bxg7 Kxg7 16. Nb5 Nf6 17. a4 Nb8 18. b4 cxb4 19. a5 Qc6 20. Qxb4 Qe4 21.
>Qd2 Qc2 22. Qxc2 Bxc2 23. Rfc1 Be4 24. Rd1 a6 25. Nc7 Nc6 26. Ng5 Bc2 27. Nxf7
>Rxf7 28. Ne6+ Kh6 29. Nxd8 Nxd8 30. Rd2 Bf5 31. Rc1 Ne4 32. Rd4 Nc6 33. Rdd1
>Rd7 34. g4 Be6 35. Bf3 Ng5 36. Bxc6 bxc6 37. Rxc6 Bxg4 38. Rdc1 Be2 39. Rb6
>Nh3+ 40. Kg2 Nf4+ 41. Kg1 Nd5 42. Rb2 Bb5 43. Rd2 Nf4 44. Rcd1 Kg5 45. f3 Kf6
>46. Kf2 Ne6 47. h4 Ng7 48. Rc2 Nf5 49. Rc7 Ke6 50. Rxd7 Bxd7 51. f4 Nxd6 52.
>Re1+ Kf6 53. Rd1 Ke7 54. Re1+ Kd8 55. Rb1 Bb5 56. Re1 Nf5 57. Rg1 Ng7 58. Re1
>Kd7 59. Kf3 h5 60. Kg2 Kd6 61. Kh2 Kd5 62. Rg1 Bd3 63. Rg2 Ne6 64. Kg3 Ke4 65.
>Rg1 Nxf4 66. Kh2 Kd4 67. Rc1 Ne6 68. Kg3 Nc5 69. Ra1 Nb3 70. Ra2 Kc4 71. Kf2
>Kb4 72. Ke3 Bf5 73. Kf4 Nxa5 74. Kg5 Bd3 75. Rd2 Kc3 76. Ra2 Nb3 77. Kf6 a5
>78. Ra4 Bb5 79. Ra2 a4 80. Kxg6 Nc1 81. Ra3+ Kb4 82. Ra1 Nb3 83. Ra2 Be8+ 84.
>Kg5 Nd4 85. Rb2+ Kc3 86. Rb8 Bc6 87. Rb6 a3 88. Ra6 Kb3 89. Ra7 a2 90. Rxa2
>Kxa2 91. Kxh5 Bd7 92. Kg6 Nf3 93. h5 Be8+ 94. Kh6 Kb2 95. Kg7 Bxh5 96. Kf6 Bg4
>97. Ke7 Kc3 98. Kf7 Kd4 99. Kf6 Kd5 100. Kf7 Kd6 101. Kf6 Be6 102. Kg7 Ke7
>103. Kg6 Bg4 104. Kh7 Kf6 105. Kg8 Nd4 106. Kh7 Bf3 107. Kg8 Be4 108. Kh8 Nc6
>109. Kg8 Nd8 110. Kf8 Ne6+ 111. Kg8 Kg6 112. Kh8 Bf3 113. Kg8 Bg2 114. Kh8 Bd5
>115. Kg8 Bc6 116. Kh8 Nf4 117. Kg8 Nd5 118. Kh8 Nb4 119. Kg8 Bd5+ 120. Kh8 Kf6
>121. Kh7 Nc6 122. Kh8 Ne5 123. Kh7 Bf3 124. Kg8 Nc6 125. Kh7 Ne7 126. Kh8 Nf5
>127. Kg8 Kg6 128. Kh8 Kf7 129. Kh7 Bd5 130. Kh8 Nd4 131. Kh7 Nf3 132. Kh8 Kf6
>133. Kh7 Nd4 134. Kh8 Be4 135. Kg8 Ne6 136. Kh8 Bd5 137. Kh7 Ng5+ 138. Kh8 Ke7
>139. Kg7 Be4 140. Kg8 Ke6 141. Kg7 Bf5 142. Kg8 Kf6 143. Kh8 Nf3 144. Kg8 Ne5
>145. Kh8 1/2-1/2
>
>
>My opinion is: this game and notation is not correct!
>
>Here my answer for Enrique Irazoqui:
>
>Hi Enrique,
>
>Thanx to M. Scheidl I now have the trnslation of your posting, as you can see
>via the quoted game annotation.
>
>Why was the game declared as a draw ? As one can easily see in the PGN
>annotation below, DF would have had to resign exactly after 3 times minus 6.5.
>Quite obvius that you know this too - and I also have critisized it quite
>clearly that GT is unable to acchieve a mate with B + N !
>
>In case DF has finally resigned in move 91 it's more or less a shame in this
>case, alas : a resign remains resign - therefore the result must be o-1 and
>surelly not 1/2.
>
>As far as I could detect it's probably your own fault here, because you didn't
>set DF to "never resign " and, because of this, continued this game. It sure may
>be fun to watch a prog that's unable to solve a position correct, while the
>other one allready shows the upcoming mate in it's own evaluation.
>
>For my personal opionion, it should be of importance ore relevance :
>
>1. What's marked 1stly, has to be respected - and this was a "resign" of DF !
>
>2. On the other hand, as allready mentioned, one sure can have his personal
>entertainment to watch one prog resign while the other one doesn't even know,
>what's going on.
>
>So, quite obvious :
>
>as done, this game should have been finished maually but the result, of course,
>coudln't be anything else than a 0-1.
>
>This is, BTW, my opinion and I sure would have acted likewise as a principle.
>
>Here the correct notation + result (by Enrique!):
>
>[Event "40'/40+40'/40+40'40/Dual P933"]
>[Site "Cadaqués"]
>[Date "2001.01.28"]
>[Round "1"]
>[White "DEEP FRITZ"]
>[Black "Gambit Tiger 1.0"]
>[Result "0-1"]
>[ECO "D97"]
>[Annotator "0.47"]
>[PlyCount "182"]
>[EventDate "2001.01.04"]
>{256MB, DeepFritz.ctg. Dual P933
>} 1. d4 {0} 1... Nf6 {1} 2. c4 {0} 2... g6 {1
>} 3. Nc3 {0} 3... d5 {0} 4. Nf3 {0} 4... Bg7 {1} 5. Qb3 {0} 5... dxc4 {1} 6.
>Qxc4 {0} 6... O-O {1} 7. e4 {0} 7... Na6 {1} 8. Be2 {0} 8... c5 {1} 9. d5 {0}
>9... e6 {1} 10. O-O {0} 10... exd5 {1} 11. exd5 {0} 11... Bf5 {1} 12. Bf4 {0}
>12... Qb6 {1} 13. Be5 {0} 13... Rad8 {0} 14. d6 {0} 14... Nd7 {1} 15. Bxg7 {0}
>15... Kxg7 {1} 16. Nb5 {0} 16... Nf6 {1} 17. a4 {last book move 0.47/13 101}
>17... Nb8 {180} 18. b4 {0.75/12 69} 18... cxb4 {96} 19. a5 {0.72/14 0} 19...
>Qc6 {173} 20. Qxb4 {0.84/14 0} 20... Qe4 {87} 21. Qd2 {0.69/12 92} 21... Qc2 {
>40} 22. Qxc2 {0.53/13 130} 22... Bxc2 {11} 23. Rfc1 {0.56/13 107} 23... Be4 {39
>} 24. Rd1 {0.63/13 82} 24... a6 {114} 25. Nc7 {0.47/14 3} 25... Nc6 {143} 26.
>Ng5 {0.47/14 0} 26... Bc2 {138} 27. Nxf7 {0.41/15 0} 27... Rxf7 {95} 28. Ne6+ {
>0.31/15 0} 28... Kh6 {102} 29. Nxd8 {0.16/15 0} 29... Nxd8 {27} 30. Rd2 {
>-0.03/15 143} 30... Bf5 {1} 31. Rc1 {0.00/14 171} 31... Ne4 {163} 32. Rd4 {
>-0.25/14 127} 32... Nc6 {152} 33. Rdd1 {0.03/15 195} 33... Rd7 {84} 34. g4 {
>0.00/16 207} 34... Be6 {123} 35. Bf3 {0.00/16 0} 35... Ng5 {92} 36. Bxc6 {
>0.00/16 0} 36... bxc6 {12} 37. Rxc6 {0.00/15 45} 37... Bxg4 {140} 38. Rdc1 {
>-0.25/15 0} 38... Be2 {123} 39. Rb6 {-0.47/15 0} 39... Nh3+ {136} 40. Kg2 {
>-0.56/18 0} 40... Nf4+ {136} 41. Kg1 {-0.53/18 0} 41... Nd5 {52} 42. Rb2 {
>-0.59/17 50} 42... Bb5 {53} 43. Rd2 {-0.84/16 72} 43... Nf4 {1} 44. Rcd1 {
>-0.69/15 58} 44... Kg5 {139} 45. f3 {-1.06/16 0} 45... Kf6 {69} 46. Kf2 {
>-1.22/16 34} 46... Ne6 {49} 47. h4 {-1.31/16 96} 47... Ng7 {78} 48. Rc2 {
>-1.59/17 127} 48... Nf5 {54} 49. Rc7 {-1.56/17 72} 49... Ke6 {1} 50. Rxd7 {
>-1.59/16 93} 50... Bxd7 {229} 51. f4 {-1.62/18 0} 51... Nxd6 {51} 52. Re1+ {
>-1.69/16 23} 52... Kf6 {32} 53. Rd1 {-1.72/16 39} 53... Ke7 {46} 54. Re1+ {
>-1.72/15 46} 54... Kd8 {77} 55. Rb1 {-1.75/16 1} 55... Bb5 {76} 56. Re1 {
>-1.72/16 38} 56... Nf5 {16} 57. Rg1 {-1.72/17 121} 57... Ng7 {1} 58. Re1 {
>-1.75/16 79} 58... Kd7 {8} 59. Kf3 {-1.81/16 160} 59... h5 {60} 60. Kg2 {
>-2.09/17 78} 60... Kd6 {60} 61. Kh2 {-2.37/18 127} 61... Kd5 {65} 62. Rg1 {
>-2.47/18 104} 62... Bd3 {1} 63. Rg2 {-2.56/18 96} 63... Ne6 {87} 64. Kg3 {
>-2.66/18 14} 64... Ke4 {62} 65. Rg1 {-2.72/18 52} 65... Nxf4 {62} 66. Kh2 {
>-2.81/17 33} 66... Kd4 {63} 67. Rc1 {-3.22/19 209} 67... Ne6 {62} 68. Kg3 {
>-3.28/18 32} 68... Nc5 {29} 69. Ra1 {-3.44/18 64} 69... Nb3 {1} 70. Ra2 {
>-3.62/19 139} 70... Kc4 {1} 71. Kf2 {-3.69/19 132} 71... Kb4 {150} 72. Ke3 {
>-3.87/21 0} 72... Bf5 {68} 73. Kf4 {-3.94/19 31} 73... Nxa5 {65} 74. Kg5 {
>-4.03/19 77} 74... Bd3 {69} 75. Rd2 {-4.47/20 173} 75... Kc3 {1} 76. Ra2 {
>-4.25/18 45} 76... Nb3 {35} 77. Kf6 {-4.53/17 29} 77... a5 {88} 78. Ra4 {
>-4.87/17 68} 78... Bb5 {110} 79. Ra2 {-4.75/19 0} 79... a4 {123} 80. Kxg6 {
>-4.75/18 36} 80... Nc1 {87} 81. Ra3+ {-4.69/18 71} 81... Kb4 {118} 82. Ra1 {
>-4.53/18 85} 82... Nb3 {143} 83. Ra2 {-4.75/18 0} 83... Be8+ {58} 84. Kg5 {
>-4.72/18 0} 84... Nd4 {135} 85. Rb2+ {-4.84/18 0} 85... Kc3 {79} 86. Rb8 {
>-4.94/18 0} 86... Bc6 {81} 87. Rb6 {-4.87/17 0} 87... a3 {52} 88. Ra6 {
>-6.00/16 60} 88... Kb3 {161} 89. Ra7 {-8.47/17 0} 89... a2 {49} 90. Rxa2 {
>-8.12/18 72} 90... Kxa2 {0} 91. Kxh5 {-13.47/19 72} 91... Bd7 {Resigns 0} 0-1
>
>Regards,
>Eduard
Hi!
What's the problem, this have no impact of the end-results. He changed the
parameter from resign late to never to as fair as possible.
He plays the whole tournament with auto-232, it is much easier to manipulate the
results if you play manually, it is a well known fact.
Bertil
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.