Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Does Analysing database BT-2630 or BS-2830 give correct Elo rating?

Author: Enrique Irazoqui

Date: 05:31:42 03/30/98

Go up one level in this thread


On March 30, 1998 at 08:01:13, Eran wrote:

>Hi,
>
>I am a little bit confused with using Analyse database menu with BT-2630
>or BS-2830 in Rebel9. I want to know the accurate Elo rating of my
>computer using Rebel9, and I am not sure if using Analyse database menu
>with BT-2630 or BS-2830 will give correct Elo rating for my computer.
>
>Does Analysing database BT-2630 or BS-2830 give correct Elo rating?

NO!!! (subtle answer)

For a number of reasons, all valid, you won't get a correct rating out
of any test suite.

It takes very many games, preferably against strong human opponents at
regular time controls. As a consequence, nobody knows for sure the
actual rating of any program.

Enrique

> Can
>I go ahead and use it easily? Will a new Analysis.dat database tell me
>about the accurate Elo rating for my computer using Rebel9?
>
>If not, should I watch carefully each time I load a position into my
>computer and write down a solution then? It is time-consuming . . . . :(
>
>Is fixed user level of 15:00 minutes correct for analysing BT-2630 or
>BS-2830 to give correct Elo rating for my computer? If not, what is the
>correct level for that please?
>
>As to finding a correct solution during analysing a position in a
>database, I am not sure exactly which move is the correct solution of a
>position. Let's suppose, if a move was found right after the program
>changed its mind the last time, then several more *same move* lines were
>found till the end of fifteen minutes, which is the correct move for a
>solution of a position, the move right after the program changed its
>mind the last time or the last move at the end of fifteen minutes?
>
>Your help is greatly appreciated. Please email me privately, too. :)
>
>Thank you,
>Eran
>Rebel9 Enduser
>Email: mrerk@earthlink.net



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.