Author: Frank Quisinsky
Date: 15:06:44 04/14/01
Go up one level in this thread
Hello Christophe, the first, a good answere ! >I have already given my point of view on this issue. This is right. >In short: >1) I still do not understand the arbitrary choice of Deep Fritz, Deep Junior and >Deep Shredder I agreed full with you ! >2) Why is the winner of such a closed tournament supposed to perform the best >against a player of a totally different kind? Also this is right ! But which qualification is better as all the tourneys which Shredder won ? We have no a better compare ! I wish me we have a better compare but unfortunately we haven´t this. Time for organize new tournaments, I say this all the years. >Please note that I do NOT question the integrity of the person chosen to do the >qualifying tournament (Enrique), and that I do NOT question the fact that these >programs are very good. Yes I full agreed in this poinst. The question is not Enrique, I think he make the best for all computer chess fans. But this idea is not good. >>You can not beat Shredder is a official tourney. So I think you must say ... the >>best program for a match against Vladimir Kramnik is Shredder. >You must be kidding. > >Franck, your objectivity was the guaranty of the good quality and interest of >your tournaments, but obviously this objectivity is fading away. No, in this poinst I have my opinion. I will World Champion 1996, 1999, 2000, IPCCC Champion 2000, 2001 CCT Master against World Champion Vladimir Kramnik. I will here see not an other program. This is for me the reward for the fantastic work from Stefan Meyer Kahlen. >>All other opinions from other chess programmer to this case are own goals. >>Sorry, but this is clear for me. >What is clear to me is that I was referring to the very funny texts you can read >on the Millennium page. I guess they can fool people with absolutely no computer >chess background, which might be the case of the majority of people reading this >pages, maybe. So maybe this kind of propaganda actually works, unfortunately. The text on the Millennium webpage is OK for me. >What is not clear to me is how you can say things like "You can not beat >Shredder in an official tourney". What are you trying to do with such a risky >useless statement? I have not see a tourney where Tiger make a better result compare to Shredder. Sorry Christophe, we all know that your program is a monster and playing really nice chess but this is for the moment not the question. If you have all the titels what do you say in this point ? I am World Champion of the latest years but I think we must play a qualification tournament with Shredder, Fritz ... This is not the right way. Best Frank > Christophe
This page took 0.03 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.