Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Nice position on the Chessbase site. (a reality check)

Author: Ernst Walet

Date: 12:29:43 04/16/01

Go up one level in this thread


On April 16, 2001 at 11:02:38, Robert Hyatt wrote:

>On April 16, 2001 at 04:24:17, Ernst Walet wrote:
>
>>
>>It suffices :)
>>
>>Ernst.
>
>
>First, a short story.  My son was looking for a used Jeep Cherokee.  He found
>one he liked and asked me to go with him to the dealer to look at it.  I went
>and when the salesman (the owner) talked with us, he told Chris that he, his
>wife, and his son all drove a jeep, that it was a good vehicle, etc.  We didn't
>pay any attention to the 'fluff' but he liked the jeep and ended up buying it
>after we took it home and gave it a thorough mechanical going-over.  A month
>later, talking to my brother, he had also bought a used vehicle for his son
>at the same dealer, but this time the vehicle was a Toyota Camry.  The owner
>told my brother "I drive one, my wife drives one and my son drives one."
>
>We finally decided that the word "drives" is the operative word here.  To me,
>"drives one" means "owns one".  But not necessarily.  :)
>
>The moral of this story is that the various chess program vendors are in the
>business of selling chess software.  If you believe everything they say, you
>will _continually_ be disappointed.  Because they will twist the truth to the
>breaking point.  Your posted position is a case in point.  One where one
>particular commercial engine does very well on, but others don't.  And then this
>position becomes a big selling point.
>
>The best way to buy a product is to look carefully at the product.  _not_ at
>the box it comes in.  Ignore the claims. The  customer praise.  The hyperbole.
>The stretched truth.  Etc.
>
>It is about marketing.  Not about chess.  :)

Thanks for your lesson, three things to add here from my side.

1. As beta tester of the Rebel company I allready was quite aware what the
Tigers can and can't so that was not the reason to post these positions, the
purpose was to entertain.

2. In this regard I was not dissapointed that I could not reproduce all the fast
times that where stated in the article.

3. To not "only look at the box", I testet the position with Century3, Fritz6
and CM8000 as well.

But of course your reality check is very true :)

Ernst.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.