Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: About the selection of the challengers

Author: Bertil Eklund

Date: 13:59:20 04/17/01



First of all these are the CONDITIONS for the match vs Kramnik.
Use of a SMP-macine with 8cpus. POINT

I was asked to recommend the STRONGEST programs for a qualifying tournament.
The qualifyer should be used to pick the BEST program and not the "luckiest".
Therefore it should be played in longer matches. Again and I repeat in order to
minimize the randomness it shouldn't be played in a short tournament in a few
rounds.

The above means that only a few programs can take part in the challenge.
What is the strongest programs of today? In my opinion, if I pick the 5-6 best
programs (one cpu), it can only be the following Deep-Fritz, Deep-Shredder,
Deep-Junior, Fritz6 and Tiger/Gambit.

Then I checked the CONDITIONS again, and what is left only the Deeps of Fritz,
Shredder and Junior. Fritz6 was a bit old anyway, so I skipped it but I really
was sorry that (after that I had seen that mr Theron wasn't planning any
SMP-version in the near future) I couldn't recommend the program(s) that may be
the strongest of all in a single-cpu event.

No there wasn't any ifs included in the stated CONDITIONS.
No Swiss-tournament in a few rounds against a bunch of GMs.

IF noone else hasn't noticed it yet, nowadays the most used word in this Forum
is IF.

I have almost seen as many suggestions as there are members in this fora.
Almost anyone seems to be absolutely sure what to do and how to do.

I only want to remind again that this is a commercial event. Meaning that there
is a time-schedule. There are rules to be followed and contracts to be signed.
I also find it quite logical that the organizer of the event want the strongest
possible program to play against Kramnik. The cost of the event is a seven
digit-number in USD.

At last before everyone starts the shouting and shouting:

I accepted the offer as a consultant, "chess-computer expert" for what it is
worth, because I really liked the idea of a match between the best program on a
8cpu-machine.

I haven't received a single cent for this, no the entry-fee wasn't supposed for
mr Irazoqui or my pockets (mr Czub as usual). I was offered a trip to the event
but if it can make someone happier I stay at home and prepare the computer for
the next SSDF hardware-level. Hopefully mr Theron can have some kind of revenge
if Tiger(s) tops the next list on the new hardware.

Bertil




This page took 0.02 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.