Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Further testing of CM_Utzinger

Author: John Merlino

Date: 16:44:39 04/30/01


I continued my testing of the CM_Utzinger personality. If you remember my
earlier testing, I merely played 100-game matches between two copies of the
default Chessmaster personality, one using the CM8000 book, and the other using
the Kostick book (which is the book used by CM_Utzinger). The 200-games tended
to show that there was little to no difference between these two books (although
200 games is in no way a large enough sample).

This time, I went in the other direction, testing the default personality
SETTINGS against the CM_Utzinger SETTINGS, but with both of them using the
CM8000 book. My theory was that, perhaps, the success of the personality might
not be due to the combination of settings+book, but rather to only one of those
two factors.

The results are less then encouraging:

100 G/10 games:
Chessmaster 55.5, CM_Utzinger 44.5 (+35 =41 -24)

100 G/60 games:
Chessmaster 52.0, CM_Utzinger 48.0 (+24 =56 -20)

So, it appears that somehow there may be a magical combination of the
settings+book that gives CM_Utzinger its power.

Meaning that I am now going to test the full package against the default
Chessmaster personality. Results by the end of the week....

jm



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.