Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Gedanken-Experiment

Author: Ingo Althofer

Date: 01:22:39 08/25/01


It seems that opening books played a key role in the Maastricht championships.

What are your opinions on the following scenario:

Take one specific chess program X, and play a double round robin tournament
where the six entrants are six copies of X, only differing by their opening
books:

(i) X + its normal book (from the commercial version of X)
(ii) X without any opening book
(iii) X + secret Kure-book
(iv)  X + secret Necchi-book
(v)   X + secret Noomen-book
(vi) X + realtime human choice from the full ChessBase database during the
opening phase (only the opening phase)

Questions:

* Is it true that (iii) - (vi) would end clearly above (i) and (ii)?
  If so, how large would the gap between the two groups be?

* How much would the success of (iii), (iv), (v) depend on whether
  X=Rebel or Tiger or Fritz or Junior or Shredder or Crafty or ...

* How would (vi) perform in comparison to (iii)-(v)?

* Which person would be an ideal human in the (vi)-team?


Ingo Althofer.

PS: The ordering in (iii) - (v) was chosen by alphabet.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.