Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Pentium 4 2.0 Gig with RDRAM vs. Athlon 1900+ with DDR PC266 1600-2100

Author: Brian Katz

Date: 09:35:29 12/30/01


  I have recently asked many questions regarding Pent 4 2.0 Gig vs the Athlon
1900+, and have received many replies. Thank you. It is greatly appreciated!
  The general consensus is that the Athlon 1900+ outperforms the Pentium 4 2.0
Gig by far when run with most chess programs.
  I was just speaking to a technician at a local PC store about this issue.
His view is that all the tests between the Athlons and the Pentium, where the
Athlons were scoring better, were with the Peniums using only SDRAM instead of
models using the faster RDRAM. He insisted that the bottleneck caused by using
the SDRAM was one of the reasons. He also stated that with RDRAM where you can
have BUS Speeds of 400-600 ( Athlon only 266) should allow the Pentium 4 to blow
the Athlon away.
  He did go on to say that the Pentium will have a 3.5 GIG processor in about a
years time. (Yes he said 3.5 GIG)
He also went on to say that the Athlon Motherboards were a bit unsteady and
caused some problems.
  I just happened to ask about getting the new Athlon 2000+ when it is
available, and would it be possible to upgrade to a DUAL 2000+ Processor? That
is when he said the Athlon Motherboards are unsteady when purchasing the
moterboards. However, the Manufacturer made computers with Athlons seemed to be
fine.

  I am ready to go out and Purchase an Athlon 2000+ as soon as they become
available, perphaps they already are.
  If anyone can shed some light on any of the issues, it would greatly
appreciated.

Thank you and Happy New Year to everyone!!



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.