Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: A Strange Result, A P-IV at 1.7 Ghz Outperforms an Athlon at I.4 Ghz!

Author: Terry McCracken

Date: 22:32:51 01/20/02

Go up one level in this thread


On January 21, 2002 at 00:54:52, James T. Walker wrote:

>On January 20, 2002 at 22:02:10, Terry McCracken wrote:
>
>>Can anyone explain how and why a P-IV at 1.7 Ghz with 512MB (PC800) RDRAM
>>outperformed an Athlon running at 1.4 Ghz with 266Mgh DDR Bus and 256MB of SDRAM
>>on a Fritzmark by a wide margin?
>>
>>The Fritzmark for the Pentium was 749 and the AMD a mere 548! Why? This is
>>contrary to the findings of this forum. That is a difference of 201, that is
>>large!
>>
>>An explantion would be appreciated, thanks!
>>
>>Terry
>
>Hello Terry,
>I don't know whose AMD you used but it's due an overhaul!  My FritzMark for my
>1.4G Athlon is 890 (1285K/nps)(32M hash).  It's an ordinary Athlon with standard
>PC133 SDRAM.
>Jim

Interesting Jim as I told a friend of mine, who owns the P-4 and tested it on
his machine and on his son's AMD machine, that his son should hit about 900 with
the Fritzmark!

I told him the Athlon was much faster but these were the results he gave me!
I questioned him about his son's machine, whether it had the right components,
and he said yes and that his son researched before he purchased the AMD machine.

I'm sorry I can't do the test myself, it really shocked me as it made little
sense to me!

I use an _old_ P-3 (Katima)sp? 500Mhz IBM Aptiva with 128MB of 100Mgh SDRAM and
get a Fritzmark of 324, so I guessed the Athlon at 1.4Ghz should be at least 3x
faster!

I agree something must be wrong with his son's AMD machine, but he replied that
his son's machine was the best he could get at the time.

It's puzzling!

Thanks for your reply!

Terry



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.