Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Deep Blue test for your favorite program

Author: Miguel A. Ballicora

Date: 10:48:23 01/31/02

Go up one level in this thread


On January 31, 2002 at 00:29:04, K. Burcham wrote:


I let the second position to run on Gaviota.
It likes Bd1, and to be honest, I like that move too.
In fact, I like it even better than f4. The idea is to
play Qa2, which will force to take with a bishop after axb5.
That creates two weaknesses on a6 and c4. There is time for
f4 later.

Regards,
Miguel

r1rq1bk1/3b1ppn/p2p3p/1p1Pp3/PPp1P3/R1P1B1NP/2B1QPP1/R5K1 w - - 0 1
+-----------------+
| r . r q . b k . |
| . . . b . x x n |
| x . . x . . . x |
| . x . o x . . . |
| o o x . o . . . |
| R . o . B . N o |
| . . B . Q o o . |
| R . . . . . K . |
+-----------------+

legal moves available = 42
        17   1       0.0    -2.28  Be3-a7   Ra8xa7   a4xb5    Bd7xb5
        37   1       0.0    -1.56  Be3xh6   g7xh6    a4xb5    a6xb5
        50   1       0.0    +0.17  Qe2-h5
        63   1       0.0    +0.57  Ng3-h5
       100   1       0.0    +0.73  a4xb5    a6xb5
       136   1:      0.0    +0.73  a4xb5    a6xb5
       169   2       0.0    +0.73  a4xb5    a6xb5    <EMPTY>  <-transp
       676   2       0.0    +0.78  f2-f4    e5xf4    Be3xf4
      1356   2:      0.0    +0.78  f2-f4    e5xf4    Be3xf4
      1544   3       0.0    +0.78  f2-f4    e5xf4    Be3xf4   <EMPTY>
                                   <-transp
      1835   3       0.0    +0.82  a4xb5    a6xb5    Ra3-a7   Ra8xa7
                                   Ra1xa7
      2534   3:      0.0    +0.82  a4xb5    a6xb5    Ra3-a7   Ra8xa7
                                   Ra1xa7
      3640   4       0.0    +0.73  a4xb5    a6xb5    Ra3-a5   Bf8-e7
      7074   4:      0.1    +0.73  a4xb5    a6xb5    Ra3-a5   Bf8-e7
      8703   5       0.1    +0.69  a4xb5    a6xb5    f2-f4    Ra8xa3
                                   Ra1xa3   <EMPTY>  <-transp
     24941   5       0.3    +0.71  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Qe2-b2
     26500   5:      0.3    +0.71  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Qe2-b2
     36866   6       0.4    +0.65  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Qe2-a2   Ra8xa3   Qa2xa3
     65420   6:      0.6    +0.65  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Qe2-a2   Ra8xa3   Qa2xa3
     86939   7       0.9    +0.77  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Be3-b6   Qd8-f8   Qe2-d2
    179693   7:      1.7    +0.77  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Be3-b6   Qd8-f8   Qe2-d2
    272135   8       2.6    +0.67  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Be3-b6   Qd8-f8   Qe2-a2   Ra8-b8
    383096   8:      3.6    +0.67  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   a4xb5    a6xb5
                                   Be3-b6   Qd8-f8   Qe2-a2   Ra8-b8
    797720   9       7.4    +0.79  Bc2-d1   Nh7-f6   Qe2-a2   g7-g6
                                   a4xb5    Bd7xb5   Bd1-e2   h6-h5
                                   Be3-g5
   1002293   9:      9.1    +0.79  Bc2-d1   Nh7-f6   Qe2-a2   g7-g6
                                   a4xb5    Bd7xb5   Bd1-e2   h6-h5
                                   Be3-g5
   1740838  10      16.1    +0.70  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   Qe2-a2   Be7-g5
                                   Be3xg5   Nh7xg5   a4xb5    Bd7xb5
                                   Bd1-g4   Rc8-b8
   3698032  10:     35.0    +0.70  Bc2-d1   Bf8-e7   Qe2-a2   Be7-g5
                                   Be3xg5   Nh7xg5   a4xb5    Bd7xb5
                                   Bd1-g4   Rc8-b8
   6977893  11      65.9    +0.75  Bc2-d1   Nh7-f6   Qe2-a2   g7-g6
                                   a4xb5    Bd7xb5   Kg1-h2   h6-h5
                                   Be3-g5   Rc8-c7   Bd1-e2
  13604928  11:    132.0    +0.75  Bc2-d1   Nh7-f6   Qe2-a2   g7-g6
                                   a4xb5    Bd7xb5   Kg1-h2   h6-h5
                                   Be3-g5   Rc8-c7   Bd1-e2

>
>here is a line played by Deep Blue and Kasparov, in game two.
>(21.Qe2 Qd8 22.b4 Qc7 23.Rec1 c4 24.Ra3 Rec8 25.Rca1 Qd8 26.f4 Nf6)
>
>below you will find the logs for Deep Blue for move 24. and 25., also included
>is the target move 26.f4.
>notice the final search line in the log for move 24. in this line you will
>notice Deep Blue finds pf2f4, at depth 11(6). this is the move Deep Blue plays
>for move 26.
>If I read the logs correctly, Deep Blue starts "thinking", out of book when
>Kasparov plays 17...Ng6.
>
>clock at move 17.  113 minutes
>clock at move 25.  89 minutes
>so from the time Deep Blue started its search, until the time it found
>  the f4 move   113-89=24     24 minutes.
>(of course we know it wasnt looking for this line with f4 the whole 24 minutes)
>that is 8 or 9 moves that Deep Blue played in this 24 minutes.
>however you choose to divide this time, lets just say we cut this time in half,
>and give your program 12 minutes to find f4. that should be fair.
>
>but really, most should start this test at night---and check it in the morning,
>or some check it when you come back from a two week vacation.
>some will find it, some wont. one program does real well.
>some see it but dont play it. one of the top programs wont play it at all.
>but it seems most all programs, if given enough time will find f4.
>how long does your favorite program take to find the line or move?
>kburcham
>
>
>harder test--looking for this line  24...Rec8 25.Rca1 Qd8 26.f4 etc..
> [D] r3rbk1/2qb1ppn/p2p3p/1p1Pp3/PPp1P3/R1P1B1NP/2B1QPP1/2R3K1 b - - 10 1
>
>
>easier test--looking for 26.f4
> [D] r1rq1bk1/3b1ppn/p2p3p/1p1Pp3/PPp1P3/R1P1B1NP/2B1QPP1/R5K1 w - - 0 1
>
>---------------------------------------
>-->  24.   Ra3 <-- 16/90:51
>---------------------------------------
>hash guess Re8c8,Guessing Rec8
> 8(4) #[Rca1](30)[Rca1](30) 30^ T=0
>rc1a1 Qc7d8 pa4b5P Pa6b5p ra3a7 Ra8a7r be3a7R
> 8(6) #[Rca1](47)######################################## 47  T=2
>rc1a1 Qc7d8 pa4b5P Pa6b5p ra3a7 Ra8a7r be3a7R
> 9(6) #[Rca1](47)######################################## 47  T=5
>rc1a1 Qc7d8 pa4b5P Pa6b5p ra3a7 Ra8a7r be3a7R
>10(6) #[Rca1](43)######################################## 43  T=35
>rc1a1 Qc7d8 bc2d1 Bf8e7 qe2a2 Be7g5
>11(6)<ch> 'rec8'  #[Rca1](43)[TIMEOUT] 43  T=227
>rc1a1 Qc7d8 pf2f4 Pe5f4p be3f4P Nh7f6 qe2f2 Pa6a5 pb4a5P
>---------------------------------------
>-->  25.   Rca1 <-- 15/89:24
>---------------------------------------
>hash guess Qc7d8,Guessing Qd8
> 8(4) #[f4](30)[f4](30) 30^ T=0
>pf2f4 Pe5f4p be3f4P Nh7f6 qe2f2 Pa6a5 pb4a5P
> 8(6) #[f4](43)######################################### 43  T=2
>pf2f4 Pe5f4p be3f4P Nh7f6 qe2f2 Pa6a5 pb4a5P
> 9(6) #[f4](43)##<ch> 'qd8'
>[221 sec (main.c:1847)][cont]####################################### 43  T=33
>pf2f4 Pe5f4p be3f4P Nh7f6 qe2f2 Pa6a5 pb4a5P
>10(6) #[f4](41)##################[Kh2](42)#######[Bd1](45)############### 45
>T=119
>bc2d1 Nh7f6 qe2a2 Ra8b8 pa4b5P Pa6b5p bd1f3 Pg7g6
>11(6) #[Bd1](43)#[f4](46)[TIMEOUT] 46  T=234
>pf2f4 Pe5f4p be3f4P Rc8b8 bf4e3 Bf8e7 pa4b5P Pa6b5p be3a7 Rb8b7
>---------------------------------------
>-->  26.   f4 <-- 14/85:39



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.