Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Report from the field. (slightly OT)

Author: Gian-Carlo Pascutto

Date: 02:34:09 02/09/02

Go up one level in this thread


On February 09, 2002 at 04:50:22, Hristo wrote:

>Here is a report from the field.
>Exactly one week ago I bought a Mac. My very first Mac.
>A dual 1GHz G4 + 1GRam and all the other normal stuff.
>I?m absolutely impressed!!! After the initial shock of everything being new and
>different I must admit that this is the easiest ?thing? to use, administer,
>configure and it is by far the prettiest interface and hardware out there. I
>still have the AMD and Intel boxez (indeed) but they have not seen much use
>lately. The only drawback, which to me is significant, is that linux+XWindows
>doesn?t run on this Mac (yet). The video card ... again, other than that
>Yellowdog linux boots just fine.
>
>The interesting thing is that the G4-1GHz outperforms the PIII-1GHz, P4-1.8GHz
>and Xeon 1.7GHz. My test was an FFT routine (class) I use at work. The code is
>not optimized in any shape or form for the G4. The worst case is when doing
>64K-samples FFT (using floats).
>
>G4 - 18 fft/sec
>Xeon 1.7 - 6.04 fft/sec
>P4 1.8 - 5.93 fft/sec
>pIII 1 - 5 fft/sec
>
>Yes ... the cache got the best out of the Intel Chipsen. ;-)
>Until this point the G4 was still better than the rest of them. All of the CPUs
>scaled ?n log(n)? in the range of 1K-...-32K samples.
>
>If interested I can send you the source code to test yourself.
>
>It, almost, seems that one can write a chess program using ?float? instead of
>?int? and still get the same performance.
>
>BTW
>Does anyone have test(s) you would like to try on a G4?! If reasonable I might
>do it.

Keep in mind the FPU of the P4 is horrible. Much slower than the Athlon.
However, it's SSE2 module is very fast _and_ optimized for just the kind
of thing you're testing. So, if possible, I'd be interesting to optimize
your code for Pentium 4 (if only by recompiling with Intel
C+autovectorization) and see what comes out.

--
GCP



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.