Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Crafty vs Crafty.....Part 2

Author: Uri Blass

Date: 05:00:58 02/17/02

Go up one level in this thread


On February 17, 2002 at 07:37:33, pavel wrote:

>On February 16, 2002 at 23:56:26, Chessfun wrote:
>
>>On February 16, 2002 at 17:31:43, pavel wrote:
>>
>>>In reply to this post :-
>>>http://www.icdchess.com/forums/1/message.shtml?213803
>>>
>>>---------------------------------------------------------------------
>>> Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws
>>>
>>>1 Crafty 17.14                   : 2580   82  75    56    61.6 %   2497   33.9 %
>>>2 Crafty 17.11                   : 2567   84  74    56    59.8 %   2498   33.9 %
>>>3 Crafty 18.12                   : 2561   85  68    56    58.9 %   2498   39.3 %
>>>4 Crafty 18.11                   : 2561   85  71    56    58.9 %   2498   35.7 %
>>>5 Crafty 18.01                   : 2555   86  65    56    58.0 %   2498   41.1 %
>>>6 Crafty 18.13                   : 2542   88  78    56    56.2 %   2499   26.8 %
>>>7 Crafty 18.10                   : 2542   88  68    56    56.2 %   2499   37.5 %
>>>8 Crafty 17.02                   : 2542   88  71    56    56.2 %   2499   33.9 %
>>>9 Crafty 18.03                   : 2536   89  72    56    55.4 %   2499   32.1
>>>%10 Crafty 17.01                  : 2536   89  72    56    55.4 %   2499   32.1
>>>%
>>>11 Crafty 18.08                  : 2524   91  67    56    53.6 %   2499   35.7 %
>>>12 Crafty 17.06                  : 2524   91  67    56    53.6 %   2499   35.7 %
>>>13 Crafty 17.04                  : 2518   92  68    56    52.7 %   2500   33.9 %
>>>14 Crafty 17.13                  : 2518   92  59    56    52.7 %   2500   44.6 %
>>>15 Crafty 16.6                   : 2512   94  66    56    51.8 %   2500   35.7 %
>>>16 Crafty 16.03                  : 2506   95  62    56    50.9 %   2500   41.1 %
>>>17 Crafty 16.13                  : 2500   83  83    56    50.0 %   2500   25.0 %
>>>18 Crafty 18.04                  : 2500   76  76    56    50.0 %   2500   35.7 %
>>>19 Crafty 16.11                  : 2494   62  95    56    49.1 %   2500   41.1 %
>>>20 Crafty 16.18                  : 2482   71  92    56    47.3 %   2501   30.4 %
>>>21 Crafty 18.06                  : 2470   70  90    56    45.5 %   2501   33.9 %
>>>22 Crafty 16.5                   : 2458   74  88    56    43.8 %   2502   30.4 %
>>>23 Crafty 18.07                  : 2452   73  87    56    42.9 %   2502   32.1 %
>>>24 Crafty 16.15                  : 2452   70  87    56    42.9 %   2502   35.7 %
>>>25 Crafty 18.02                  : 2452   73  87    56    42.9 %   2502   32.1 %
>>>26 Crafty 16.04                  : 2427   76  83    56    39.3 %   2503   32.1 %
>>>27 Crafty 16.1                   : 2408   81  80    56    36.6 %   2504   30.4 %
>>>28 Crafty 14.12                  : 2408   81  80    56    36.6 %   2504   30.4 %
>>>29 Crafty 15.20                  : 2368   87  75    56    31.2 %   2505   30.4 %
>>>
>>>-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>>
>>>
>>>Something tell me I am in for a BIG surprise...
>>>
>>>;)
>>>
>>>pavs
>>
>>
>>Single PC Deep Fritz GUI, TB 1200, ponder=off.
>>All 5 piece bases, 5/0. 2600.ctg. All play all 2x = 812 games.
>>
>>Program                  Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws
>>
>> 1 Crafty 17.13        : 2573   83  69    56    60.7 %   2498   39.3 %
>> 2 Crafty 18.07        : 2555   86  65    56    58.0 %   2498   41.1 %
>> 3 Crafty 16.18        : 2555   86  65    56    58.0 %   2498   41.1 %
>> 4 Crafty 17.01        : 2549   87  66    56    57.1 %   2499   39.3 %
>> 5 Crafty 18.08        : 2549   87  63    56    57.1 %   2499   42.9 %
>> 6 Crafty 17.14        : 2542   88  61    56    56.2 %   2499   44.6 %
>> 7 Crafty 18.12        : 2542   88  61    56    56.2 %   2499   44.6 %
>> 8 Crafty 18.13        : 2542   88  68    56    56.2 %   2499   37.5 %
>> 9 Crafty 18.06        : 2536   89  59    56    55.4 %   2499   46.4 %
>>10 Crafty 18.03        : 2536   89  62    56    55.4 %   2499   42.9 %
>>11 Crafty 18.10        : 2530   90  73    56    54.5 %   2499   30.4 %
>>12 Crafty 16.11        : 2524   91  67    56    53.6 %   2499   35.7 %
>>13 Crafty 17.06        : 2512   94  61    56    51.8 %   2500   42.9 %
>>14 Crafty 18.01        : 2506   95  56    56    50.9 %   2500   48.2 %
>>15 Crafty 17.04        : 2506   95  56    56    50.9 %   2500   48.2 %
>>16 Crafty 16.5         : 2506   95  67    56    50.9 %   2500   33.9 %
>>17 Crafty 18.04        : 2494   62  95    56    49.1 %   2501   41.1 %
>>18 Crafty 17.11        : 2494   59  95    56    49.1 %   2501   44.6 %
>>19 Crafty 15.20        : 2488   72  94    56    48.2 %   2501   28.6 %
>>20 Crafty 17.02        : 2482   71  92    56    47.3 %   2501   30.4 %
>>21 Crafty 18.11        : 2482   65  92    56    47.3 %   2501   37.5 %
>>22 Crafty 16.15        : 2482   65  92    56    47.3 %   2501   37.5 %
>>23 Crafty 16.6         : 2470   63  90    56    45.5 %   2501   41.1 %
>>24 Crafty 16.03        : 2470   54  90    56    45.5 %   2501   51.8 %
>>25 Crafty 18.02        : 2458   68  88    56    43.8 %   2502   37.5 %
>>26 Crafty 16.13        : 2446   72  86    56    42.0 %   2502   33.9 %
>>27 Crafty 14.12        : 2402   80  79    56    35.7 %   2504   32.1 %
>>28 Crafty 16.1         : 2389   86  77    56    33.9 %   2504   28.6 %
>>29 Crafty 16.04        : 2375   65  75    56    32.1 %   2505   46.4 %
>>
>>Make of it what you want. But I think you lost the bet Pavel?.
>>
>>Sarah.
>
>
>how did I loose the bet?
>crafty 18.13 is still not the number one in your list.
>ver 17.13 is top in your list and 17.14 in mine.... wondering how much
>differance in strength does these ver. have?

based on your list
Crafty17.14=2580
Crafty17.13=2518
crafty18.13=2542

based on the Sarah's list:
crafty17.14=2542
Crafty17.13=2573
crafty18.13=2542

You can see that Crafty18.13 is a stable engine when 17.14 and 17.13 have no
idea what is their rating(

Crafty18.03 is the second best stable engine with a rating of 2536

Not that I consider this as important.

Uri



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.