Author: Uri Blass
Date: 06:40:42 02/17/02
Go up one level in this thread
On February 17, 2002 at 08:59:01, pavel wrote: >On February 17, 2002 at 08:00:58, Uri Blass wrote: > >>On February 17, 2002 at 07:37:33, pavel wrote: >> >>>On February 16, 2002 at 23:56:26, Chessfun wrote: >>> >>>>On February 16, 2002 at 17:31:43, pavel wrote: >>>> >>>>>In reply to this post :- >>>>>http://www.icdchess.com/forums/1/message.shtml?213803 >>>>> >>>>>--------------------------------------------------------------------- >>>>> Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws >>>>> >>>>>1 Crafty 17.14 : 2580 82 75 56 61.6 % 2497 33.9 % >>>>>2 Crafty 17.11 : 2567 84 74 56 59.8 % 2498 33.9 % >>>>>3 Crafty 18.12 : 2561 85 68 56 58.9 % 2498 39.3 % >>>>>4 Crafty 18.11 : 2561 85 71 56 58.9 % 2498 35.7 % >>>>>5 Crafty 18.01 : 2555 86 65 56 58.0 % 2498 41.1 % >>>>>6 Crafty 18.13 : 2542 88 78 56 56.2 % 2499 26.8 % >>>>>7 Crafty 18.10 : 2542 88 68 56 56.2 % 2499 37.5 % >>>>>8 Crafty 17.02 : 2542 88 71 56 56.2 % 2499 33.9 % >>>>>9 Crafty 18.03 : 2536 89 72 56 55.4 % 2499 32.1 >>>>>%10 Crafty 17.01 : 2536 89 72 56 55.4 % 2499 32.1 >>>>>% >>>>>11 Crafty 18.08 : 2524 91 67 56 53.6 % 2499 35.7 % >>>>>12 Crafty 17.06 : 2524 91 67 56 53.6 % 2499 35.7 % >>>>>13 Crafty 17.04 : 2518 92 68 56 52.7 % 2500 33.9 % >>>>>14 Crafty 17.13 : 2518 92 59 56 52.7 % 2500 44.6 % >>>>>15 Crafty 16.6 : 2512 94 66 56 51.8 % 2500 35.7 % >>>>>16 Crafty 16.03 : 2506 95 62 56 50.9 % 2500 41.1 % >>>>>17 Crafty 16.13 : 2500 83 83 56 50.0 % 2500 25.0 % >>>>>18 Crafty 18.04 : 2500 76 76 56 50.0 % 2500 35.7 % >>>>>19 Crafty 16.11 : 2494 62 95 56 49.1 % 2500 41.1 % >>>>>20 Crafty 16.18 : 2482 71 92 56 47.3 % 2501 30.4 % >>>>>21 Crafty 18.06 : 2470 70 90 56 45.5 % 2501 33.9 % >>>>>22 Crafty 16.5 : 2458 74 88 56 43.8 % 2502 30.4 % >>>>>23 Crafty 18.07 : 2452 73 87 56 42.9 % 2502 32.1 % >>>>>24 Crafty 16.15 : 2452 70 87 56 42.9 % 2502 35.7 % >>>>>25 Crafty 18.02 : 2452 73 87 56 42.9 % 2502 32.1 % >>>>>26 Crafty 16.04 : 2427 76 83 56 39.3 % 2503 32.1 % >>>>>27 Crafty 16.1 : 2408 81 80 56 36.6 % 2504 30.4 % >>>>>28 Crafty 14.12 : 2408 81 80 56 36.6 % 2504 30.4 % >>>>>29 Crafty 15.20 : 2368 87 75 56 31.2 % 2505 30.4 % >>>>> >>>>>----------------------------------------------------------------------------- >>>>> >>>>> >>>>>Something tell me I am in for a BIG surprise... >>>>> >>>>>;) >>>>> >>>>>pavs >>>> >>>> >>>>Single PC Deep Fritz GUI, TB 1200, ponder=off. >>>>All 5 piece bases, 5/0. 2600.ctg. All play all 2x = 812 games. >>>> >>>>Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws >>>> >>>> 1 Crafty 17.13 : 2573 83 69 56 60.7 % 2498 39.3 % >>>> 2 Crafty 18.07 : 2555 86 65 56 58.0 % 2498 41.1 % >>>> 3 Crafty 16.18 : 2555 86 65 56 58.0 % 2498 41.1 % >>>> 4 Crafty 17.01 : 2549 87 66 56 57.1 % 2499 39.3 % >>>> 5 Crafty 18.08 : 2549 87 63 56 57.1 % 2499 42.9 % >>>> 6 Crafty 17.14 : 2542 88 61 56 56.2 % 2499 44.6 % >>>> 7 Crafty 18.12 : 2542 88 61 56 56.2 % 2499 44.6 % >>>> 8 Crafty 18.13 : 2542 88 68 56 56.2 % 2499 37.5 % >>>> 9 Crafty 18.06 : 2536 89 59 56 55.4 % 2499 46.4 % >>>>10 Crafty 18.03 : 2536 89 62 56 55.4 % 2499 42.9 % >>>>11 Crafty 18.10 : 2530 90 73 56 54.5 % 2499 30.4 % >>>>12 Crafty 16.11 : 2524 91 67 56 53.6 % 2499 35.7 % >>>>13 Crafty 17.06 : 2512 94 61 56 51.8 % 2500 42.9 % >>>>14 Crafty 18.01 : 2506 95 56 56 50.9 % 2500 48.2 % >>>>15 Crafty 17.04 : 2506 95 56 56 50.9 % 2500 48.2 % >>>>16 Crafty 16.5 : 2506 95 67 56 50.9 % 2500 33.9 % >>>>17 Crafty 18.04 : 2494 62 95 56 49.1 % 2501 41.1 % >>>>18 Crafty 17.11 : 2494 59 95 56 49.1 % 2501 44.6 % >>>>19 Crafty 15.20 : 2488 72 94 56 48.2 % 2501 28.6 % >>>>20 Crafty 17.02 : 2482 71 92 56 47.3 % 2501 30.4 % >>>>21 Crafty 18.11 : 2482 65 92 56 47.3 % 2501 37.5 % >>>>22 Crafty 16.15 : 2482 65 92 56 47.3 % 2501 37.5 % >>>>23 Crafty 16.6 : 2470 63 90 56 45.5 % 2501 41.1 % >>>>24 Crafty 16.03 : 2470 54 90 56 45.5 % 2501 51.8 % >>>>25 Crafty 18.02 : 2458 68 88 56 43.8 % 2502 37.5 % >>>>26 Crafty 16.13 : 2446 72 86 56 42.0 % 2502 33.9 % >>>>27 Crafty 14.12 : 2402 80 79 56 35.7 % 2504 32.1 % >>>>28 Crafty 16.1 : 2389 86 77 56 33.9 % 2504 28.6 % >>>>29 Crafty 16.04 : 2375 65 75 56 32.1 % 2505 46.4 % >>>> >>>>Make of it what you want. But I think you lost the bet Pavel?. >>>> >>>>Sarah. >>> >>> >>>how did I loose the bet? >>>crafty 18.13 is still not the number one in your list. >>>ver 17.13 is top in your list and 17.14 in mine.... wondering how much >>>differance in strength does these ver. have? >> >>based on your list >>Crafty17.14=2580 >>Crafty17.13=2518 >>crafty18.13=2542 >> >>based on the Sarah's list: >>crafty17.14=2542 >>Crafty17.13=2573 >>crafty18.13=2542 >> >>You can see that Crafty18.13 is a stable engine when 17.14 and 17.13 have no >>idea what is their rating( >> >>Crafty18.03 is the second best stable engine with a rating of 2536 >> >>Not that I consider this as important. >> >>Uri > > >right I really don't know what to make out of it, >but crafty 18.13 surely isn't the best version at blitz IMO ;) > >pavs Maybe it is not the best but I cannot be sure about it based on the information that is given Crafty17.14 is the best if you combine both tournament and the average difference between it and 18.13 based on the the 2 tournaments is only 19 elo. 19 elo is not significant when you have only 112 games for every program. Uri
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.