Author: Will Singleton
Date: 20:41:51 03/03/02
Go up one level in this thread
On March 03, 2002 at 23:33:10, John Merlino wrote: >On March 03, 2002 at 21:31:16, Will Singleton wrote: > >>On March 03, 2002 at 17:49:16, John Merlino wrote: >> >>>On March 03, 2002 at 15:44:41, Jon Dart wrote: >>> >>>>Recently Arasan had this position against Gandalf on ICC: >>>> >>>>[D] 8/p5kp/1pBnP1p1/8/8/P3P3/4K2P/8 w - - >>>> >>>>Arasan played e7? here and lost. It had limited time here: it switches >>>>off e7 pretty quickly, and prefers Kd3, but continues to give White a >>>>positive score. >>>> >>>>On the other hand, a variety of other programs I've tried (Crafty, >>>>Hiarcs 7, and Pharaon) play e4 here with a negative score for White. >>>> >>>>I'd be interested in any comments on this endgame. e7? is a loser, >>>>but is Black still better if White avoids this? >>>> >>>>--Jon >>> >>>Here's what Chessmaster says: >>> >>>Time Depth Score Positions Moves >>>0:00 5/6 0.29 11360 1.e4 Kf8 2.Kd3 Ke7 3.e5 Nf5 >>>0:00 6/7 0.09 24852 1.e4 Kf8 2.Kd3 Ke7 3.e5 Nf5 4.Bd7 >>> Ng7 >>>0:00 7/8 0.22 59680 1.e4 Kf8 2.Kd3 Ke7 3.Bd7 b5 4.e5 >>> Nc4 >>>0:01 8/9 -0.26 156594 1.e4 Kf8 2.Kd3 Ke7 3.e5 Nf5 4.Bd7 >>> Ng7 5.Ke4 Nxe6 >>>0:02 8/9 -0.15 291263 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 b5 4.Kd5 >>> a5 5.Bc6 >>>0:06 9/10 -0.12 658367 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 Nf5+ >>> 4.Ke4 b5 5.Ke5 Nxe3 6.Bxb5 Ng4+ >>> 7.Kf4 Nxh2 >>>0:12 10/11 -0.15 1465984 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 h6 4.Kd5 >>> b5 5.e4 a5 6.e5 >>>0:25 11/12 -0.18 3282649 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 Nf5+ >>> 4.Ke4 h6 5.a4 a6 6.h3 b5 7.axb5 >>> Nd6+ 8.Kd5 axb5 >>>1:00 12/13 -0.18 7869328 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 Nf5+ >>> 4.Ke4 h6 5.a4 a6 6.h3 b5 7.axb5 >>> Nd6+ 8.Kd5 axb5 >>>2:16 13/14 -0.28 17722817 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 Nf5+ >>> 4.Ke4 a6 5.a4 b5 6.axb5 axb5 7.Kd3 >>> Nd6 8.Kc3 h6 >>>5:56 14/15 -0.30 46635573 1.Kd3 Kf6 2.Bd7 Ke7 3.Kd4 Nf5+ >>> 4.Ke4 a6 5.a4 b5 6.axb5 axb5 7.Kd3 >>> Nd6 8.Kc3 h6 9.Kb4 >>> >>>jm >> >>position after your line Kd3 Kf6 Bd7 Ke7 Kd4 Nf5+ >>[D] 8/p2Bk2p/1p2P1p1/5n2/3K4/P3P3/7P/8 w - - >> >>Ke4 looks like the best move, but the score seems to go south for White soon >>after. My program plays the line Kd5! NxP Kc6 (kb7 kxa7 etc) which seems to >>draw. I wonder if it does draw, and if so, will any program play Kd5. >> >>Will >> >>ps: Jon, my prog plays Kd3 with a slight + for white, which goes negative after >>awhile. > >After your position, CM8000 still likes Ke4: > >Time Depth Score Positions Moves >0:00 3/4 -0.10 1629 1.Ke4 Nd6+ 2.Kd5 b5 3.Bc6 a5 >0:00 4/5 -0.12 5313 1.Ke4 b5 2.Ke5 Nxe3 3.Bxb5 Ng4+ > 4.Kf4 Nxh2 >0:00 5/6 -0.14 14011 1.Ke4 b5 2.Ke5 Nd6 3.Kd5 a5 >0:00 6/7 -0.15 36030 1.Ke4 b5 2.Ke5 Nd6 3.Kd5 a5 4.Bc6 >0:01 7/8 -0.13 118644 1.Ke4 Nd6+ 2.Kd5 b5 3.Kc5 a6 4.Kb6 > Nc4+ 5.Kxa6 Nxa3 6.Bxb5 Kxe6 >0:03 8/9 -0.34 300107 1.Ke4 Kd6 2.Kf4 Ng7 3.Kg5 Nxe6+ > 4.Bxe6 Kxe6 5.Kh6 Ke7 6.Kxh7 g5 >0:06 9/10 -0.30 745191 1.Ke4 a6 2.a4 b5 3.axb5 axb5 4.Kd3 > Nd6 5.Kc3 h6 6.Kb4 >0:14 10/11 -0.27 1642465 1.Ke4 a6 2.a4 h6 3.h3 b5 4.axb5 > axb5 5.Kd3 Nd6 6.Kc3 g5 >0:30 11/12 -0.33 3679209 1.Ke4 a6 2.a4 Kd6 3.Kf4 h6 4.Be8 > Ne7 5.Bd7 Nd5+ 6.Kf3 Nf6 7.Bc8 >1:40 12/13 -0.30 12335386 1.Ke4 a6 2.h3 h6 3.a4 Kd6 4.Be8 > Ng7 5.Bxg6 Nxe6 6.Kf3 Nc5 7.Bc2 > Ke5 >3:58 13/14 -0.33 29553878 1.Ke4 Kd6 2.Kf4 h6 3.Be8 Ne7 4.Bf7 > a5 5.Ke4 b5 6.Kd3 b4 7.axb4 axb4 > 8.Kc2 > >After forcing Kd5, it says: > >Time Depth Score Positions Moves >0:00 3/4 -0.78 4490 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kd4 Nf5+ 3.Kd5 Nd6 > 4.Bc6 a6 >0:00 4/5 -0.86 10247 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kd4 Ng4 3.h3 Nf6 4.Bc8 >0:00 5/6 -0.82 20284 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kd4 Ng4 3.h3 Nf6 4.Bc8 > h6 5.Ke5 >0:01 6/7 -0.86 89455 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Nc4 3.a4 Nd6 4.h3 > h6 5.Kd5 a6 >0:03 7/8 -0.91 268628 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kd4 Nf5+ 3.Kd5 Nd6 > 4.Bc6 b5 5.h3 g5 6.Bd7 a5 7.Bc6 >0:05 8/9 -0.92 569074 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Nc4 3.a4 Nd6 4.Kc7 > g5 5.Kc6 h5 6.Kd5 a6 >0:10 9/10 -1.42 1181683 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Nc4 3.Kb7 Nxa3 > 4.Kxa7 b5 5.Kb6 b4 6.Kc5 b3 7.Kd4 >0:16 10/11 -1.09 1958586 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Nc4 3.a4 Ne5+ 4.Kc7 > g5 5.Bc8 g4 6.Kb8 a6 7.Kc7 b5 >0:31 11/12 -1.21 3875436 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Nc4 3.a4 Ne5+ 4.Kc7 > h5 5.Bc8 Nf3 6.Kb7 Nxh2 7.Kxa7 > Nf3 8.Kxb6 >1:18 12/13 -1.21 9869253 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Nc4 3.a4 Ne5+ 4.Kc7 > h5 5.h4 a5 6.Bc8 Nf3 7.Kxb6 Nxh4 > 8.Kxa5 Nf3 9.Kb6 >3:26 13/14 -1.45 26172248 1...Nxe3+ 2.Kc6 Ng4 3.h3 Ne5+ 4.Kc7 > g5 5.Bb5 Kxe6 6.Kb7 Kd5 7.Kxa7 > Kc5 8.Be2 b5 9.Ka6 Nc4 > >....doesn't look good.... > >jm John, No, it doesn't. But, strangely enough, Ke4 loses, while Kd5 draws. Chessmaster misses the continuation after 2.. Ng4, which is Kb7. imvho, of course. :) Will
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.