Author: James T. Walker
Date: 04:30:38 03/16/02
Concerning the 50 move draw rule. While playing Shredder Paderborn last night,
Shredder claimed a draw by the 50 move rule and terminated the auto232 game.
When looking at the games this morning I noticed that in the ChessPartner GUI
the game was saved as a win for Chess Tiger. I guess the reason is that since
it was Shredder's turn to move only Shredder could claim the draw. Since
Tiger's last move announced mate in 13, expecting to win a knight on the next
move, Tiger claimed the win. How do other programmers handle this problem?
Here is the game.
[Event "5 Minutes/Game"]
[Site "auto232 match"]
[Date "2002.03.16"]
[Round "49"]
[White "Shredder Paderborn"]
[Black "Chess Tiger 14.0"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
1. d4 {book 0s} d5 {0s (Nf6)} 2. Nf3 {book 0s} Nf6 {0s}
3. c4 {book 0s} c6 {3s} 4. cxd5 {book 0s} cxd5 {0s} 5. Bf4
{book 0s} Nc6 {0s} 6. Nc3 {book 0s} Bf5 {0s} 7. e3 {book
0s} e6 {0s} 8. Qb3 {book 0s} Bb4 {0s} 9. Bb5 {book 0s} O-O
{0s} 10. O-O {book 0s} Qe7 {0s (Bxc3)} 11. Bxc6 {book 0s}
bxc6 {0s} 12. Na4 {book 0s} Nh5 {0s} 13. a3 {book 0s} Ba5
{8s} 14. Rac1 {-0.01/10 10s} Rfc8 {12s} 15. Bg5 {+0.18/12
1s} f6 {11s} 16. Bh4 {+0.30/12 0s} g5 {10s (Rab8)} 17. Bg3
{+0.14/10 4s} Nxg3 {3s (e5)} 18. hxg3 {+0.13/11 4s} Rab8
{9s (e5)} 19. Qd1 {+0.38/11 6s} Bd8 {0s (Bb6)} 20. Qe2
{+0.24/10 9s} Qb7 {0s (a5)} 21. Nd2 {+0.05/10 5s} Be7 {5s
(Qb5)} 22. b4 {+0.14/12 11s} a5 {5s (Qb5)} 23. g4 {+0.24/12
13s} Bg6 {11s} 24. bxa5 {+0.32/13 0s} Bxa3 {6s (Qb5)}
25. Ra1 {+0.69/11 6s} Qe7 {0s (Bb4)} 26. e4 {+0.58/9 6s}
Rb5 {5s (Rd8)} 27. a6 {+1.04/9 6s} Ra8 {0s (Bb2)} 28. Rfe1
{+0.34/10 8s} Qd6 {9s (dxe4)} 29. exd5 {+0.29/10 12s} exd5
{5s} 30. Rxa3 {+0.08/11 3s} Qxa3 {5s} 31. Qe6+ {0.00/11 0s}
Bf7 {5s (Kg7)} 32. Qxf6 {+0.06/10 5s} Qd3 {6s (Qxa4)}
33. Nf3 {+0.27/10 5s} Qg6 {5s} 34. Qxg6+ {+0.38/12 3s} Bxg6
{2s} 35. Nc5 {+0.38/11 0s} Rb1 {8s (Rb4)} 36. Rxb1
{+0.35/12 5s} Bxb1 {0s} 37. Ne5 {+0.73/14 3s} Ba2 {9s}
38. Nxc6 {+0.61/16 0s} Bc4 {4s} 39. Nb4 {+0.78/12 0s} Kf7
{7s} 40. g3 {+0.60/13 1s} Kg6 {2s (Re8)} 41. Kg2 {+0.65/12
11s} h5 {0s (Rb8)} 42. gxh5+ {+0.61/13 22s} Kxh5 {1s}
43. f3 {+0.55/12 9s} g4 {0s} 44. Ne6 {+0.47/11 9s} gxf3+
{5s} 45. Kxf3 {+0.01/13 1s} Bxa6 {3s} 46. Nf4+ {+0.01/12
3s} Kg5 {8s} 47. Ne6+ {0.00/13 3s} Kh6 {4s (Kh5)} 48. Nc7
{+0.01/12 3s} Rf8+ {2s} 49. Ke3 {+0.01/13 2s} Bb7 {5s}
50. Ncxd5 {+0.01/13 0s} Rf1 {4s (Kg5)} 51. Kd2 {0.00/10 3s}
Rb1 {6s (Rf2+)} 52. Kc3 {-0.01/9 2s} Rg1 {19s (Bxd5)}
53. Nb6 {-0.03/9 8s} Rxg3+ {3s} 54. Kc4 {-0.23/10 2s} Kg5
{6s} 55. d5 {-0.04/11 0s} Kf5 {4s} 56. Kc5 {-0.04/10 2s}
Rg1 {10s (Ke4)} 57. Nc4 {-0.01/9 2s} Kf6 {5s} 58. Nd6
{-0.01/10 0s} Ba8 {3s (Rc1+)} 59. Nc6 {-0.01/10 2s} Re1
{12s (Rc1+)} 60. Kc4 {-0.01/12 2s} Kg7 {2s (Bxc6)} 61. Nf5+
{-0.01/8 3s} Kg6 {4s} 62. Nfd4 {-0.02/10 4s} Kf7 {11s
(Rc1+)} 63. Kc5 {-0.01/9 1s} Ke8 {5s (Rc1+)} 64. Nf3
{-0.01/10 0s} Rc1+ {1s} 65. Kd6 {-0.01/18 0s} Rb1 {1s
(Bxc6)} 66. Nd2 {-0.01/10 0s} Rd1 {1s} 67. Ne4 {-0.01/15
0s} Kf7 {0s (Bxc6)} 68. Ne5+ {0.00/8 0s} Kg7 {1s (Ke8)}
69. Nc3 {+0.01/9 0s} Ra1 {1s (Rc1)} 70. Ke6 {+0.01/8 0s}
Kf8 {0s (Bxd5+)} 71. Nd7+ {+0.01/8 1s} Ke8 {2s} 72. Nc5
{+0.01/14 0s} Rc1 {2s (Kd8)} 73. N3e4 {+0.01/12 0s} Kd8 {0s
(Bxd5+)} 74. Kd6 {+0.01/11 0s} Rf1 {2s (Rd1)} 75. Ne6+
{0.00/11 0s} Kc8 {0s} 76. Ke5 {+0.01/11 0s} Re1 {1s (Rd1)}
77. N6c5 {0.00/9 0s} Kd8 {0s (Bb7)} 78. Kd6 {-0.01/11 0s}
Rb1 {2s (Rd1)} 79. Ne6+ {+0.01/12 0s} Kc8 {3s} 80. Nf6
{+0.01/14 0s} Rb7 {0s (Rd1)} 81. Ke5 {-0.01/11 0s} Rb5 {2s}
82. Kd6 {0.00/12 0s} Ra5 {1s (Rb7)} 83. Ke7 {+0.01/12 0s}
Ra7+ {0s (Bxd5)} 84. Kd6 {-0.01/11 0s} Rf7 {1s (Ra6+)}
85. Ke5 {+0.01/15 0s} Rb7 {0s (Rxf6)} 86. Ne8 {+0.01/11 0s}
Rb2 {2s (Rd7)} 87. Nd6+ {+0.01/10 0s} Kd7 {0s} 88. Ne4
{+0.01/10 0s} Re2 {1s (Bxd5)} 89. Nf4 {-0.01/10 0s} Re1
{1s} 90. Ne6 {-0.01/12 0s} Re3 {1s (Bb7)} 91. Kd4 {0.00/8
0s} Re2 {1s (Rh3)} 92. Ke5 {0.00/7 0s} Re1 {1s (Ke7)}
93. N6c5+ {-0.01/11 0s} Kc8 {2s (Ke7)} 94. Ne6 {0.00/12 0s}
Kb8 {1s (Bb7)} 95. Nd4 {0.00/10 0s} Bb7 {1s (Kc8)} 96. Ne6
{-0.01/10 0s} Re2 {1s (Rd1)} 97. Nf4 {0.00/9 0s} Re3 {0s}
98. Kd4 {-0.01/9 0s} Re1 {1s (Rf3)} 99. Nc5 {-0.01/9 0s}
Ba8 {1s (Kc8)} 100. d6 {+0.01/8 0s} Bc6 {1s (Kc8)} 101. d7
{+0.01/7 0s} Rd1+ {1s (Re8)} 102. Kc3 {+0.01/8 0s} Rd6 {0s}
103. Nfe6 {+0.01/9 0s} Bxd7 {0s} 104. Nxd7+ {+0.01/12 0s}
Rxd7 {0s} 105. Kc4 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd2 {0s (Ka8)} 106. Kc5
{-0.01/4 0s} Kc8 {0s (Ka8)} 107. Kc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd1 {0s
(Kb8)} 108. Kc5 {-0.01/4 0s} Kd7 {0s (Kb8)} 109. Nf8+
{-0.01/4 0s} Ke7 {0s (Kc7)} 110. Ng6+ {-0.01/4 0s} Ke6 {0s
(Kd7)} 111. Nf4+ {-0.01/4 0s} Ke5 {0s} 112. Ng6+ {-0.01/4
0s} Ke4 {0s} 113. Ne7 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd7 {0s (Ra1)} 114. Nc6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rd5+ {0s (Ra7)} 115. Kc4 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd2 {0s
(Ra5)} 116. Kc5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rc2+ {0s (Ra2)} 117. Kd6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rc1 {0s (Rxc6+)} 118. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd1+
{0s (Kd4)} 119. Ke6 {-0.01/4 0s} Re1 {0s (Kd4)} 120. Kd6
{-0.01/4 0s} Re2 {0s (Kd4)} 121. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rc2 {0s
(Ra2)} 122. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd2+ {0s (Kd4)} 123. Ke6
{-0.01/4 0s} Re2 {0s (Kd4)} 124. Kd6 {-0.01/4 0s} Re1 {0s
(Kd4)} 125. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rd1+ {0s (Ra1)} 126. Ke6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rc1 {0s (Ra1)} 127. Kd6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rc3 {0s
(Rxc6+)} 128. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rh3 {0s (Kd4)} 129. Nc6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rh2 {0s (Rh6+)} 130. Ke6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rg2 {0s
(Rh6+)} 131. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rb2 {0s} 132. Kd6 {-0.01/4
0s} Rf2 {0s (Kd4)} 133. Ke6 {-0.01/4 0s} Ra2 {0s (Kd4)}
134. Kd6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rh2 {0s (Kd4)} 135. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s}
Rf2 {1s (Rh6+)} 136. Ke6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rb2 {0s (Rf6+)}
137. Kd6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rg2 {0s (Rb6)} 138. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s}
Ra2 {0s (Kd4)} 139. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Ra1 {0s} 140. Ne7
{-0.01/4 0s} Rf1 {0s (Rc1)} 141. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rf6+ {0s
(Rd1+)} 142. Kc5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rf3 {0s (Rxc6+)} 143. Kd6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rf1 {0s (Ra3)} 144. Ke6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rg1 {0s
(Rf6+)} 145. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rg3 {0s (Kd4)} 146. Kd6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rg5 {0s (Kd4)} 147. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rg6+ {0s
(Ra5)} 148. Kc5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rg3 {0s (Rxc6+)} 149. Kd6
{-0.01/4 0s} Rg1 {0s (Ra3)} 150. Ne5 {-0.01/4 0s} Rh1 {0s
(Kd4)} 151. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rb1 {0s (Rh6+)} 152. Ne5
{-0.01/4 0s} Ra1 {0s (Kd4)} 153. Nc6 {-0.01/4 0s} Rh1 {0s
(Ra6)} 154. Ne5 {0.00/4 0s} Rh6+ {0s (Kd4)} 1/2-1/2
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.