Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: When not to delete a post

Author: Dan Newman

Date: 15:19:02 07/09/98

Go up one level in this thread


On July 09, 1998 at 13:36:31, Bruce Moreland wrote:

<snip>
>I didn't get any email from Ed.  Did anyone else get email from Ed or not get
>it?  Would some threshold level of "I didn't get the mail" and "I got it, but I
>signed up on Ed's site, or at least might have" convince him?

I got Ed's email that day--and rather enjoyed getting it.  At the
time, I think I briefly thought "maybe Ed got my address from
CCC"--it would be quite easy to get.  But, the problem is that the
address to which Ed sent his email, "dnewman@bellatlantic.net", isn't
the one that's listed here in the "Posted by Dan Newman" line--I've
been intending to get that changed...

Also, I have visited his site maybe a dozen times and have downloaded
Rebel Decade.  I suspect that it may have been a condition to download
that you give your email address--I don't remember.

>As a side-topic, do we want to have a delete-profanity-on-sight system?
>Personally I don't care either way, I can live with either kind of situation.
>Some people seem to feel pretty strongly though.
>
>bruce

Hmm.  The problem is that different people have different levels of
tolerance for "profanity".  Each person has his own set of words that
he finds objectionable--for some this is the null set, others...

I don't mind a bit of profanity as long as it isn't directed at
someone and is only used to describe or to indicate the intensity
of one's own subjective reaction to something--and can be clearly
understood to be such.  I guess I don't think profanity should be
a reason to delete all by itself--there should have to be a strong
element of personal attack.

In fact I don't think profanity should ever be given as a reason for
a deletion, as that would allow the party whose post was deleted a
reason to complain of unfair bias against him.  He would be able to
dredge up other posts with "profanity" that weren't deleted as
"evidence" of that bias.

-Dan.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.