Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Unauthorized use of Rebel books

Author: Marc van Hal

Date: 16:39:09 04/30/02

Go up one level in this thread


On April 30, 2002 at 15:45:54, Gian-Carlo Pascutto wrote:

>On April 30, 2002 at 15:20:05, Miguel A. Ballicora wrote:
>
>>Note that this would mean that Tiger won't be able to use a Noomen book
>>if Rebel is present, and Rebel or Tiger won't be able to use the Nalimov's
>>tablebases if Crafty is present (assuming that Nalimov participates as part
>>of the Crafty team as I used in the example).
>
>I think it is obvious from the example, that this could cause
>more problems than it solves.
>
>Right now the tournaments already provide an exception for
>Nalimov's code. If you would apply the general rule to openings
>books, both Rebel and ChessBase would be in trouble (multiple
>Noomen and Kure books)
>
>--
>GCP

Ehm where does my position comes in then?
Not to mention the work of much other theoreticans
Who by the way did copyright their work!
Just pointing to most of the comercial openingsbooks
Rebel, Fritz, Junior,Tiger an so on

I am not a lawman but I know a bit how copyright works
You have to make a precise description of what of the work you created
made it unique from the rest.
And this many times can be a hard job.
Especialy if someone else came up with the idea to copyright it before you did
Like some chesspublishers did with my work.
But I still know how to copyright my work because they left enough space open.

I think it is also more simple then the copyright of an openingsbook for a
chessprogram.(If I insert the moves from the testgames from the top of the SSDF
list in a book it is likely that some of the special moves from your book will
come in that book,which is nothing but a legal action!)
Then again that you did not fully  work out analyses gives it a better chance
But I would simply again make a special openingsbook
of positions which Rebel or Tiger like above the rest like the Tiger book was
ment to be.
And after the position is clear for Rebel or Tiger
Instead of a theoretical openingsbook
Leaving the option of copying the openingsbook useles
I also think I can help you with that
At the moment I am building an openingsbook which starts with Tal's reportoir
Which I build up to the present theory.
I also have done this with several other World champions in the past.
Building up books from scratch in this way is much work
But I am not lazy which most of you will know.
We also live in a country which registers the most copyrights !
So that again should give you hope.
Hoping for suport from a chess federation will not realy work I think
Because they are just as knowlegeable as the comon people when it comes to
copyrights.
I know that the Rebel openings book already has a build in safety because I
tried to import it in diferent versions from Shredder
changing the encryption with the same program will not realy help against the
people who cracked it before.
Maybe  other encryption software might help.
Hehe then again they should send the upcoming internetpolice to my house
for their exames.

Regards                                        Marc



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.