Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: A challenge! (CPU vs CPU)

Author: Vincent Diepeveen

Date: 09:22:32 05/07/02

Go up one level in this thread


On May 06, 2002 at 22:17:42, Slater Wold wrote:

for DIEP the P4 is 70% slower than K7. Note that
K7 has lineair performance, P4 doesn't for DIEP
(stupid small L1 datacache and other things probably).

2.53Ghz = 1.7x ==> x = 1.5Ghz K7

So a dual 1.53Ghz K7 is faster for DIEP than that new thing
of yours. Not to mention price...

>Ok, so it's time to put this old horse out to pasture.........
>
>First and foremost, let me state that I _do_ believe that AMD is the current
>"king" of CPUs.  They offer great performance, at a reasonable price.  However,
>there seems to be this delusional thinking, that anyone who buys a P4 is a
>complete moron, and should be immediatly flamed for thinking it's a half decent
>CPU.  Therefore..........
>
>I am going to BUY a BRAND SPANKIN' NEW, P4 2.53Ghz machine.
>
>I currently own a dual AMD 1.73Ghz machine.  Benchmarks against my machine are
>not a problem.  I encourage ANYONE out there who would like to challenge this
>machine, to try.
>
>HOWEVER:
>
>1.) Chess is NOT the only program that runs on the computers of the world.  If
>we're going to compare apps, let's compare apps.  Benchmarks, test suites,
>whatever.  I will test whatever engine you'd like, but that's NOT going to be
>the basis of the challenge.
>
>2.) Don't try to compare some Dr. Jeykl computer to a computer running stock
>speeds.  If you want to compare IT MUST BE AIR COOLED.  (Yea, this is for YOU
>Aaron!)
>
>3.) I GUARANTEE, the new P4 will beat anything out there, in overall
>performance.
>
>
>If you think this is the part where I say, "..anyone who can beat it, wins it.."
>you're nuts.  Maybe some other time.  I will however, buy whoever can prove to
>me that they have a CPU that is BETTER overall than this 2.53Ghz, a copy of your
>favorite chess program (that would be, THE FIRST PERSON).  ;)
>
>We are not comparing price, clock speed, this, that, or the other thing.  We're
>comparing ONE thing.  Performance.
>
>
>Good luck.  :)



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.