Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: can GM's learn from programs

Author: K. Burcham

Date: 07:13:29 05/21/02



not discussing opening book moves.
not discussing egtb's.
not discussing a pawn promotion.



lets start out saying GM eval is 0, and program eval is 0.
lots of time left on both clocks. time is not an issue.

the GM makes a move and plays what he sees as a safe move.
GM took three minutes to move, but he cannot see the material winning
combination for the program.
the program takes three more minutes to see material winning move.
finally program plays winning move, and GM can see combination.

program wins.

If GM's cannot learn strategy from programs, if GM's can only learn tactics,
then the question is:  in the above described game , it would seem that most of
the time the GM cannot learn tactics either. if the combination is too deep for
the GM to see he loses material, then he cannot see this in another game.

Just wondering how a GM can learn from home practice with programs.
it would seem that in a postion were the GM could play a losing move and he
cannot see the deep combination, but the program can, he could not have won
anyway.

maybe some will answer that this is not possible. maybe some will say there
is no posiiton that the program can see winning material but GM cannot.

of course i am not refering to an simple oversight by the GM. i am not refering
to a simple human blunder. i am refering to a situation that the GM says he
could not see the combination until it was played out.

kburcham





This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.