Author: Arturo Ochoa
Date: 23:56:10 07/15/02
Go up one level in this thread
>>>13. Additional Rule 2 >>>Each participant should mention the book author(s) in the list of program >>>authors. The participant is obliged to allow the Tournament Director to inspect >>>the opening book for its contents and origine. ..." >>> >>>The only word that I don't like in these Rules are the word "should" in the Rule >>>13. Instead of, the Rule must say: >>> >>>"Each participant MUST mention the book author(s)..." > >Is it really so that no engine used a Carlos Pesce book? >I think probably the table is incomplete or in error. I don't know Dann. But, the Openings of the Chess Programs didn't have the sign of the Pesce's lines. > >>>As Jeroen Noomen has pointed out several times in this Forum, it is not >>>permissible to use any book without the Book Creator Authorization. >>> >>>As the Diep Book Tournament Creator, it is not a clean competition to use any >>>Book for a chess program during a Tournament without revealing who is the >>>Creator. >>> >>>>I don't think that eliminates anything except most of the chess programs. >>> >>>This is not true. >>> >>>1) Read the Page 4 of the WCCC 2002 Bulletin 5: >>> >>>http://www.cs.unimaas.nl/Olympiad2002/bulletin/Bulletin5.doc >>> >>>There, you can read a Table with all the Book Creators of the chess programs. I >>>don't see any program using ANY BOOK. Every Author pointed out the Source of the >>>Book, including a pgn source for some Books. > >For those that name an author, the author is not the same as the program. I >suspect that the others have some sort of help or used a special PGN collection >(perhaps TWIC or something, but there is no mention for most of the programs). > I use several sources but mainly books and my own analyses. I don't know what the rest does this work or what pgn files, but I can suspect what pgn of free databases. ;) >>>2)Read the information of Leiden 2002] >>> >>>http://www.computerschaak.nl/partic02t.html >>> >>>Here again, you can read the complete information of the Opening Book Creators. >>>When not mentioned, it means the same Chess Program Author created the Book. >>> >>>>I doubt if anyone except Vincent wrote his own book. >>> >>>No, this is not correct. Alexander Kure writes the Fritz, Brutus and Nimzo >>>Books. Jeroen Noomen writes the Tiger and Century Books and so on. Carlos Pesce >>>writes books for several Amateur Engines and so on..... > >Yes, that is what I said. The engine authors generally do NOT write their own >books. You seem to have read the opposite of what I have written. > Let's do it by this way. It is possible that I have understood the opposite, but the sentence was too general and the English is not my native language and this was a nice ideas exchange about his crtitical topic. BW, Arturo.
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.