Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Question for Dan Corbit

Author: Arturo Ochoa

Date: 00:33:29 07/16/02

Go up one level in this thread



>
>ok this is what I was talking about. everyone here knows these guys
>are consulting other GM moves and lines---all these moves and lines have been
>played by GMs. These GM have spent years studying to be able to play these
>opening lines on a GM level. then these non GM level "book builders" come along
>and move around a few positions in the lines and call this "his own book".
>I do not doubt at all what you say that these special program books add elo.
>I am amazed that these guys claim "ownership" with these books and are offended
>by someone else using them.

Hello:

1) When you are preparing for live Tournament, you also consult GM Moves and you
choose what the most appropiated moves are for your style.

2) Correction: These "guys", as you call them, have also spent years in
compilling, testing and proving many moves for the respective programs.

3) Correcction II: This "Non GM Level" has generally a Elo beyond 2000 and they
are more useful doing this kinf of work than a GM..

4) Correction III: They don't mobe around a few position. They move around
hundred of thousands of positions to find the best move for a specific chess
program and this is not a process to see "few" pgn file as you can say.

5) Correction IV: When a Chess Writer writes a book about any Topic, he uses
reference from other Chess Author. The work of compiling, investigating and
putting new view of points is enough to claim his "ownership" over his book.
Don't you agree? In this sense, these "GUYS" as you call them, do the same work
but for an specific chess program.

In this sense, it is better to know the hard work that this "GUYS" do to say
that they are compilling a few lines and that's all.

Regards, Arturo Ochoa M.



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.