Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Two of the Deep Blue moves protested by GM Kasparov

Author: Rolf Tueschen

Date: 08:07:15 07/22/02

Go up one level in this thread


On July 22, 2002 at 10:59:47, Sune Fischer wrote:

>
>>Now let's take a look at DB2. Except the 6 games from 1997 we have not a
>>single gamescore of the practice of the machine. The first game of the show
>>event reveiled that DB2 was as weak as typical machines. Some moves were
>>absolutely nonsense. The main line leading to its loss wasn't foreseen, which is
>>typical for machines.
>
>Well....
>I'm sitting here reading an article:
>
>"IMB's Deep blue chess grandmaster chips"
>page 80 - Performance:
>"The earliest games, in early 1997, used a single chip running at 70% clock
>speed and at one-tenth to one-fifth efficiency as the result of a hardware bug.
>This reduced the chip to 7% to 14% of its regular speed, or about the same
>search speed as the fastest commercial chess programs on a pentium pro 180 MHz
>PC. Two of the commercial programs, running on the pentium pro pc, served as
>opponents in the early chip debugging sessions. Of the 10 games played, the
>single-chip program won all 10. This gives about 95% confidence level that a
>single chip, even at reduced speed, was at least 200 points stronger than the
>commercial chess programs in the machine-versus-machine play.
>  We played another 30 games with either the single-chip version or Deep Blue
>Jr. against the commercial chess programs. Of the 40 games total, the chess
>chip(s) lost two points and scored 95 percent against the PC programs.
>...
>This rating has no bearing on the real playing strength, as cursory examination
>showed serious positional weaknesses in the commercial progams that the
>chess-chip systems exploited repeatedly.
>...
>The more interesting games pitted Deep Blue Jr. against the Grandmasters working
>on the project. The Grandmasters' average rating were in the high 2500s on the
>international scale. Deep Blue Jr. scored better than three-to-two against them,
>which placed it at 2700 plus, or among the top 10 players in the world."
>
>-S.

Thanks, but where are the game scores???

Rolf Tueschen



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.