Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Chessmaster 9000 v Aristarch Test Games (LONG)

Author: pavel

Date: 14:04:02 08/09/02

Go up one level in this thread


On August 09, 2002 at 15:30:08, John Merlino wrote:

>Over the past few days, I have played Chessmaster 9000 against Aristarch in two
>10-game matches. The first one was at G/15, and the second at G/30. The computer
>was a PIII-600, and pondering was OFF for both programs. Otherwise, both
>programs were using their default books and settings.
>
>In the G/15 tournament, CM9000 won 6-4 (+4 =4 -2).
>In the G/30 tournament, CM9000 won 7-3 (+6 =2 -2).
>
>The PGN games follow.
>
>Particularly exciting were the last G/15 game (which Aristarch won) and the 7th
>G/30 game. In the latter, CM9000 thought it was winning right after Aristarch
>played 18.Rad1, but Aristarch had drawish scores all the way until 45...Rd7, at
>which point Aristarch's eval jumped up to -5 within two moves. This is an
>example which goes against Dr. Hyatt's rule that says "99.9% of the time a queen
>is at least as good as two rooks".
>
>Just about the only criticism I (a lowly patzer) could have against Aristarch is
>that it seems to get into time trouble fairly easily. There were many instances
>in the G/15 match in which Aristarch would take over 40 seconds for what
>appeared to me to be an obvious move, and in the G/30 match, it would quite
>often take more than one minute for such a move. In one G/15 game, it had less
>than 5 minutes on its clock after 30 moves. The King, on the other hand, is
>notorious for being very stingy with its time, and by the early middle game
>would have as much as four more minutes on its clock (in a G/15 game).
>
>Additionally, the first two of the G/30 games had to be adjudicated in
>Aristarch's favor, due to its "simple promotion" implementation, in which it
>does not send a promotion character (e.g. "h7h8"). This is treated as an illegal
>move in Chessmaster, and Aristarch would have lost on time otherwise.
>
>However, Aristarch is an EXCEPTIONALLY exciting engine, especially when pitted
>against The King. I intend to do a 20-game G/60 match over the weekend, or,
>perhaps, a much shorter 40/120 match.
>
>Enjoy!

Yes Aristarch Time management in "game in x minutes" is probably not so good (I
am not so sure though), but 40 moves in 40 minutes seems to work great.
I have played some games myself, and Aristarh played almost equal to Hiarcs 8
and shredder6 on those following games.

And now against Fritz7 it's winning games!

I agree that it is exceptionall interesting program, the last time I was so
excited about a new free program was when YACE first came out.

cheers,
pavs



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.