Computer Chess Club Archives

Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: with text, this time :-)

Author: Mike S.

Date: 00:38:29 08/20/02

On August 20, 2002 at 01:03:48, martin fierz wrote:

>(...)
>what i found really interesting about nunn's comparison is things like
>tartakower's Qxf6+??, which i would not have expected. the problem is, of these
>guys there are only very little games published, of course only their best. the
>rest has been forgotten, and rightly so :-)

Yes... I have compared your 2 examples with the Karlsbad 1911 tournament book,
with comments by Vidmar. He gave ?? to Süchting's move O-O??, but did not
comment on Tartakover's Qxf6?.

(Süchting probably was happy that a6 was pinned, and overlooked that the d6
square was guarded by Black; without that, Nd6+ could have forked Black's K and
Q after ...Qxb5.)

I agree to what you wrote about Nunn + computer of course.

Regards,
M.Scheidl

Re: with text, this time :-) martin fierz 01:57:47 08/20/02
Re: with text, this time :-) Dann Corbit 00:41:39 08/20/02
- Re: with text, this time :-) Uri Blass 01:26:52 08/20/02
  - Re: with text, this time :-) Mike S. 01:41:46 08/20/02
- Re: with text, this time :-) Mike S. 01:24:30 08/20/02
  - Re: with text, this time :-) Roy Eassa 07:48:17 08/21/02
  - Re: with text, this time :-) Dann Corbit 01:41:35 08/20/02
    - Re: retrocomputed elo are meaningless!? martin fierz 02:08:33 08/20/02
      - Re: retrocomputed elo are meaningless!? Dann Corbit 11:19:05 08/20/02
        
        Re: retrocomputed elo are meaningless!? martin fierz 13:01:59 08/20/02
  - Re: with text, this time :-) Uri Blass 01:39:36 08/20/02
    - Re: with text, this time :-) martin fierz 02:03:36 08/20/02
    - Re: with text, this time :-) Mike S. 01:46:46 08/20/02
      - Re: with text, this time :-) Uri Blass 02:57:11 08/20/02
        
        Re: with text, this time :-) Albert Silver 15:22:18 08/20/02
        
        Re: with text, this time :-) Dann Corbit 15:52:29 08/20/02
        
        Re: with text, this time :-) Albert Silver 16:13:38 08/20/02

This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.