Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Stuart, your reasoning does make sense

Author: stuart taylor

Date: 18:24:44 10/03/02

Go up one level in this thread


On October 03, 2002 at 00:46:11, Telmo Escobar wrote:

>On October 02, 2002 at 20:56:19, stuart taylor wrote:
>
>
>>And the first 3 games are statistically much more substantial than any other 3, >even consecutive, somewhere later on.
>>
>
> >S.Taylor
>
>
>>maybe you should go back to school...
>   > Christophe
>
>>That's a bit deeper than what you are thinking about!
>>
>>to me it is quite an intriguing subject, and I'm sure there is more than what
>>meets the eye. It must be looked into some time by someone like Einstein, or
>>even by some of us, together.
>>I don't really have the head and time for it now, but no one has ever responded
>>much to some of my thoughts.
>>(I think Nunn would appreciate this subject)
>
> >S.Taylor
>
> Stuart, I feel you are right. This is deep and for this reason people, even
>intelligent people, can misunderstand the point when they think about it.
> Yet people, even dupes, understand the point perfectly when they have to apply
>it in real life.
>
> Let me explain: let us assume that I have uttered some 2000000 statements till
>now. If somebody (God, say) has recorded the stuff and selects three consecutive
>statements from mine, apparently stupid, to prove that I'm a dupe, you don't
>need to feel convinced. Maybe God, as pervert as usual, has selected three rare
>cases of particularly foolish affirmations (made, who knows, when I was drunk or
>the like) in order to fool you.
> But if you just meet me for the first time, and the first three statements of
>mine that you hear are stupid ones, you will deduce that I am a dupe, and that
>will be a quite reasonable deduction.
>
>   Telmo

Yes! I meant it along those lines. You illustrated it quite nicely!
S.Taylor



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.