Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Ludicrous promotion question

Author: Robert Henry Durrett

Date: 09:33:33 09/02/98

Go up one level in this thread


On September 02, 1998 at 01:06:23, Serge Desmarais wrote:

>On September 01, 1998 at 22:04:32, Danniel Corbit wrote:
>
>>Is it possible to promote a pawn to a pawn? [i.e. no change?]
>>I know it makes no sense.  I just want to know if it is legal by the rules of
>>chess.
>
>
>   Nope! A pawn, when it reaches respectively the 8th rank for White and the 1st
>rank for Black, MUST be changed for any piece of ITS OWN COLOUR, EXCEPT a pawn
>or a king. In fact, the is changed IN GETTING to the last square of its file.
>The move is NOT completed until the new piece enters the board, which means that
>you cannot press your clock button until you put the new piece on board (though
>if NO piece of the kind you want is available at around, you can stop the clocks
>while you go get one). Also, there must not be a too long hesitation from you
>before putting the new piece in play (you cannot push a white pawn on the eight
>rank and wait 5 minutes to decide what piece to chose from!) It must be done, as
> most as possible, in 2 consecutive and "fluid" movements. Often, the pawn
>doesn't effectively reach the last rank, it is removed from the 7th (for White,
>for example) and the new piece is almost simultaneously placed on the eth rank
>(same column).
>
>Note, the same rule concerning the fluidity of your gestures is applied to a
>capture (moving a piece onto an occupied square AND immediately removing the
>captured piece from the board) to the castle and to the en passant capture. All
>these "special" 2-movements moves are considered ONE legal move and every step
>must be completed before it is considered done and you be allowed to press your
>clock.
>
>Serge Desmarais

That having been said, how many people are there who, in over the board speed
chess tournaments, or in standard-time-control games with players both in
extreme time trouble, who have not observed the following, and maybe even done
it themselves?

(1) In blitz:  Although "illegal," someone makes an illegal move and the
opponent does not catch it till the game has progressed a few moves.
Specifically, someone pushes a pawn to the eighth rank and then it is instantly
captured by the opponent after which he punches the clock and the game
continues.  No-one complains.  The game just continues.
(2) In extreme time-control situations, after one player pushes a pawn to the
eighth rank and says "Queen!" and there are no pieces off the board to replace
the eighth rank pawn with:  Play continues, with the new pawn taking on the
powers of the queen.  That "pawn" might zip clear across the board, or even
checkmate the enemy king in a back-rank mate!



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.