Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Fritz5 has an unfair disadvantage in mclane's tournament

Author: Amir Ban

Date: 11:33:11 09/13/98

Go up one level in this thread


On September 13, 1998 at 13:12:52, Bruce Moreland wrote:


>I think that since Thorsten is known to be an anti-Fan of Fritz, that he should
>take especially careful steps to make sure that he gets the computer set up
>right, selects the right book and gets it set up right, and documents the games
>so that people can play them through and understand the opening book choices.
>
>It sounds like Fritz dynamically changes its opening book weights, so it will be
>hard to verify the book.
>

If the PowerBook resides on CD-ROM, it is not modified by learning and is in its
original state. If it was copied to disk, there's a Fritz function to restore
all book weights to original. Even simpler, you can turn off the effect of book
learning (but the "optimal" setting of Fritz actually turns it to maximum).

I think the "correct" way to use the PowerBook is in their original state
without effects of learning. Still, even if the weights have been changed by
learning, it does not make sense to argue that this makes Fritz weaker, because
learning is supposed to make Fritz stronger (and if it doesn't, this is not
Thorsten's fault).

The only "wrong" way to use the PowerBook is to change the weights artificially,
something that Fritz5 allows.

The argument that Fritz is getting a bad deal because the PowerBook is not the
best book for Fritz should be ignored even if it's true (I don't think so),
because ChessBase publish it as the strongest book for Fritz and that's all
Thorsten needs to know.

Amir




This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.