Author: Uri Blass
Date: 10:03:46 11/19/02
Go up one level in this thread
On November 19, 2002 at 12:49:37, Roy Eassa wrote: >On November 19, 2002 at 11:09:38, Uri Blass wrote: > >>On November 19, 2002 at 10:22:26, Ricardo R Santana wrote: >> >>>Hello All >>> >>>some years ago, I heard the best book was the Nimzo ones. And now, what is the >>>best commbercial book ? Of course a book should take into account the engine, >>>but who follow this statement ?? >>> >>>thanks >>>Ricardo Sant Ana >> >>I do not know but the ruffian book seems to be very good for Ruffian at 120/40 >>time control. >>Ruffian as one of the newcomers is ranked above Tiger15 and chessmaster9000 >> >>See http://www.fsv.de/chess-server/Tournaments/tournamentsection.htm >> > > >Are you referring to this table, from that site? It's sure to generate >controversy: > > > Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws > > 1 Gambit Tiger 2.0 2643 56 64 92 70.1% 2495 35.9% > 2 Fritz 7a 2618 58 66 92 66.8% 2496 31.5% > 3 Ruffian 1.0.1 2615 112 164 24 79.2% 2383 25.0% > 4 Deep Shredder 2614 58 60 92 66.3% 2496 37.0% > 5 Deep Fritz 2602 60 62 92 64.7% 2497 33.7% > 6 Deep Junior 7 2602 60 70 92 64.7% 2497 25.0% > 7 Chess Tiger 15.0 2574 116 111 24 75.0% 2383 41.7% > 8 Chessmaster 9000 2574 116 111 24 75.0% 2383 41.7% > 9 Hiarcs 8 2556 65 52 92 58.2% 2499 40.2% >10 TheKing 3.12 2552 66 52 92 57.6% 2499 39.1% >11 Gromit 3.10.2 2548 66 53 92 57.1% 2499 38.0% >12 Gandalf 5.1 2541 67 49 92 56.0% 2499 42.4% >13 Shredder 6 2537 68 54 92 55.4% 2500 34.8% >14 Yace 0.99.56 (Berlin) 2523 70 48 92 53.3% 2500 41.3% >15 Nimzo 8 2519 71 48 92 52.7% 2500 42.4% >16 Rebel Century 4 2512 72 51 92 51.6% 2501 35.9% >17 Crafty 18.08 2490 49 72 92 48.4% 2502 40.2% >18 SOS 11/2000 2479 54 70 92 46.7% 2502 32.6% >19 Gromit 3.8.2 2465 57 68 92 44.6% 2503 30.4% >20 Gandalf 4.32h 2465 51 68 92 44.6% 2503 39.1% >21 Pharaon 2.50 2457 50 67 92 43.5% 2503 41.3% >22 LambChop 10.88 2425 52 58 104 37.5% 2514 38.5% >23 Comet B37 2404 58 55 104 34.6% 2515 34.6% >24 Capture R01 2394 54 54 104 33.2% 2515 39.4% >25 CSTal 2.03 2364 57 52 104 29.3% 2516 39.4% >26 Green Light Chess 2.18h 2360 69 51 104 28.8% 2517 28.8% >27 PatzerUCI 3.61 (Leiden) 2352 72 51 104 27.9% 2517 26.9% > Yes I was refering to that table Ruffian ,Tiger15,Chessmaster9000 played 24 games against the same opponents but ruffian scored more points. I did not analyze the games to find if the reason is a better book of ruffian relative to the commercial programs. Uri
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.